The reviews lean towards approval rather than outright enthusiasm, with positive and mixed assessments but no negative verdicts. Hugh Grant is the clearest point of agreement: critics repeatedly praise his comic timing and controlled portrayal of Will, even when the film itself wins only qualified approval. Nicholas Hoult also earns praise for his performance and chemistry with Grant. The warmer accounts find the comedy funny, irreverent and refreshingly unsentimental, with an unlikely friendship that gives the coming-of-age story its appeal.
The main divide concerns how successfully the humour and emotion work together. Digital Spy finds the storytelling both hilarious and affecting, while Variety considers it pleasant but short on laughs and emotional involvement, finding the emotional climax manufactured. The Guardian admires Grant’s intelligence but misses his earlier comic energy and questions the film’s earnestness. The spread is appreciable rather than polarised, though several partial reviews offer too little accessible detail to establish their reasoning.
