
The consensus on Big Eyes is mixed, leaning towards modest approval. Amy Adams attracts the most consistent praise for giving Margaret Keane sympathy, anxiety and a growing resolve, even when critics find the surrounding drama thin. The period design, San Francisco imagery and Burton’s attention to Keane’s paintings also earn approval. Several reviews welcome his move towards more grounded storytelling; The Guardian finds an insightful account of Margaret’s struggle to claim authorship.
The divide is over how deeply the film explores that struggle, with verdicts ranging from thoughtful and engaging to dramatically inert. Reservations cluster around conventional storytelling, shallow characterisation and an unsettled tone. Christoph Waltz is particularly divisive: The Hollywood Reporter praises his performance, while Variety finds him overpowering. Many reviews argue that the film raises questions about art, exploitation and recognition without examining them closely enough, though its warmer notices find substance in those same themes.
S
Screen Daily
14 November 2014 · Tim Grierson
80*
The critic sees the film as one of Burton’s most thoughtful and accomplished works in years. He singles out Burton’s successful move away from fantasy, horror and science fiction.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
28 December 2014 · Mark Kermode
80*
Kermode finds the film an insightful, grown-up return to form for Burton. He praises Amy Adams’s sympathetic portrayal of Margaret Keane and the film’s account of her struggle to claim authorship.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
19 December 2014 · Charlotte O'Sullivan
75*
O'Sullivan finds the biopic nimble and distressing, and a welcome change of pace for Tim Burton. She singles out the film's magnetic big-eyed imagery and its playful ambiguity about whether Keane's art is grotesque or gorgeous.
Read the full review →R
RogerEbert.com
24 December 2014 · ★★★/4 · Matt Zoller Seitz
75
The review regards the film as an engaging account of artistic creation and exploitation. It singles out Amy Adams’s performance as a key strength.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
23 December 2014 · B- · A.A. Dowd
70
Dowd finds the film an underwhelming, overly square biopic, despite some surface pleasures. He praises its mid-century San Francisco atmosphere but criticizes the passive portrayal of Margaret and distracting narration.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
14 November 2014 · Todd McCarthy
70*
McCarthy finds the film nimble and enjoyable, though less strange and resonant than Burton’s Ed Wood. He singles out Amy Adams and Christoph Waltz’s performances, along with the period design and San Francisco cinematography, for praise.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
25 December 2014
64*
The article appears to be a review of Tim Burton’s film, but the page content is inaccessible. Its verdict and any specific praise or complaint cannot be verified from the available text.
Read the full review →E
Empire
1 January 2013 · Ian Freer
60*
Freer finds the film entertaining but flawed, with its uneven tone and lack of depth holding it back. He praises Amy Adams’s compelling performance and the fascinating true story, while criticizing Christoph Waltz’s over-the-top portrayal.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
20 December 2014 · 3/3/2 · David Jenkins
60
The critic finds the biopic brisk but shallow, faulting Burton for missing the story’s subtext. The review praises the stranger-than-fiction premise while noting that the film barely examines the artistic and psychological questions it raises.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★ · Emma Simmonds
60
The review finds Burton’s treatment of the true story kitsch and amusing. It praises how his soft, cartoonish visual style suits Margaret Keane’s paintings.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
22 December 2014 · ★★★ · James Mottram
60
The review finds the film watchable but ultimately ordinary. It praises Amy Adams’s performance while criticizing Christoph Waltz’s characterization as caricature rather than character.
Read the full review →V
Vulture
29 December 2014 · David Edelstein
60*
Edelstein finds the film engaging but uneven, with Christoph Waltz’s broad performance undermining Amy Adams’s work. He singles out the final stretch as tingly suburban-noir fun.
Read the full review →I
IndieWire
14 November 2014 · C · Eric Kohn
57
Kohn finds the film a bland, pedestrian drama that fails to deepen its compelling story. He praises its lush cinematography and polished visuals, while noting that Amy Adams provides a more credible source of tension.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
22 December 2014 · ★★ · Dave Calhoun
40
The review finds the true-life drama peculiar and disappointing. It singles out Christoph Waltz’s performance as overplayed.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
8 December 2014 · ★½/4 · Matt Brennan
38
Brennan finds the film timid and inconsequential, with its social questions reduced to shallow caricature. He praises Amy Adams’s affecting portrayal but criticizes the direction and thin characterization.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
24 December 2014 · Betsy Sharkey
35*
Sharkey finds the film too conventional and its portrait of Margaret Keane insufficiently realized. She praises the visual design and Burton’s handling of the courtroom painting scene.
Read the full review →V
Variety
14 November 2014 · Justin Chang
30*
Chang finds the biopic shallow and unpersuasive, despite Amy Adams’s affecting performance. He praises Adams for giving Margaret a compelling center, while faulting Christoph Waltz’s overpowering performance for leaving the film little room to breathe.
Read the full review →The critic finds the film dramatically inert and lacking insight. They single out Amy Adams’s passive characterization and Christoph Waltz’s miscasting as major weaknesses.
Read the full review →D
Digital Spy
29 December 2014 · ★★★★ · Simon Reynolds
80
The review calls the film a return to form for Burton, though it says Christoph Waltz’s tonal shifts weaken the courtroom scenes. It singles out Amy Adams’s steely performance and the film’s exploration of artistic recognition for praise.
Read the full review →C
Collider
23 December 2014 · B · Matt Goldberg
77
Goldberg considers the film Burton’s best since Big Fish, while noting reservations about his suitability to tell Margaret Keane’s story. He praises the film’s thoughtful exploration of gender, authorship, and the pressures of commercial art.
Read the full review →C
Consequence
25 December 2014 · Justin Gerber
75*
Gerber finds Big Eyes a welcome, visually arresting return to personal storytelling for Burton, despite some shortcomings. He praises the performances and rich cinematography, while noting that the final act strains to make its points.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
24 December 2014 · Pete Hammond
70*
Hammond gives the film a positive recommendation, calling it funny and weird. He singles out the terrific performances by Amy Adams and Christoph Waltz.
Read the full review →H
HeyUGuys
24 December 2014 · Amon Warmann
70*
Warmann finds Big Eyes an enjoyable, thought-provoking film, though its narrative lacks depth and subtlety. He praises the performances, especially Amy Adams’s portrayal of Margaret’s changing confidence.
Read the full review →The critic finds the film a welcome, human improvement in Tim Burton’s recent work, though ultimately good rather than great. Amy Adams’s anxious, poignant performance stands out, while the film’s reluctance to explore its questions limits its sophistication.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
22 December 2014
64*
The page appears to be a review of the specified film, but its contents are inaccessible. The critic’s verdict and any specific praise or complaint cannot be determined.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
26 December 2014 · ★★★ · Simon Brew
60
The review finds Big Eyes an entertaining but surprisingly small success, held back by an unsettled tone and rushed storytelling. It praises Burton’s attentive treatment of Margaret Keane’s paintings, while faulting the thin characterization and the leads’ performances.
Read the full review →S
The Skinny
18 December 2014 · ★★★ · Josh Slater-Williams
60
The review finds Big Eyes a more engaging and interesting film than Burton’s recent work, despite its unevenness. It praises Amy Adams’s strong lead performance and the film’s melodramatic stretches, while faulting choppy storytelling and ill-fitting comedy.
Read the full review →P
Paste
23 December 2014 · 5.8/10 · Melissa Weller
58
Weller finds the film’s feminist aims and dramatic story undermined by familiar storytelling and Burton’s restrained style. She singles out the performances as honest but hollow, with Amy Adams effective yet bored.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate