Most critics find Calm with Horses an affecting crime drama, with praise centred on Cosmo Jarvis’s performance as an enforcer caught between criminal loyalty and fatherhood. The reviews repeatedly credit him with making the character’s violence, vulnerability and tenderness convincing. Barry Keoghan and Niamh Algar also draw praise, while the rural setting and tense atmosphere give the familiar material a strong sense of place. The positive notices value the quieter character scenes as much as the threat of violence.
Reservations cluster around the crime story, which several critics find conventional, thin or poorly balanced with the family drama. IndieWire also objects to the limited roles given to women. The spread runs from enthusiasm to substantial reservations, though even the less persuaded reviews tend to admire Jarvis. The Hollywood Reporter finds the drama sluggish and its stakes low, making it a notable dissent from the broader praise for the film’s tension.
i
The i Paper
12 March 2020 · ★★★★ · Saskia Baron
80
Baron finds the film excellent and says it sustains sympathy for Arm despite his being manipulated into terrible acts. She praises Barry Keoghan’s chilling performance and the stark landscapes, while faulting the direction’s overuse of dramatic music.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
9 March 2020 · ★★★★ · Helen O’Hara
80
O’Hara praises the film as an inspired, layered crime drama. She singles out its claustrophobic portrayal of the limited horizons of rural towns and criminal gangs.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
11 March 2020 · ★★★★ · James Mottram
80
The critic finds the film tightly scripted, forcefully directed, and invigorating despite its familiar plot. Cosmo Jarvis’s magnetic performance as a damaged man torn between family and criminal loyalty is singled out for praise.
Read the full review →I
IndieWire
31 July 2020 · B · Ryan Lattanzio
77
The critic calls it a moving, confidently directed crime fable, though its criminal plot is simple and its women are mostly disposable. Cosmo Jarvis’s anguished lead performance is the film’s standout strength.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
16 March 2020
70*
The critic finds the film engaging despite its basic dramatic construction. They single out Cosmo Jarvis’s performance and the gentler, poetic scenes for praise.
Read the full review →V
Variety
11 September 2019 · festival review · Dennis Harvey
68*
Harvey finds the crime drama engrossing, though its story becomes more conventional as it moves toward revenge-thriller territory. He particularly praises the vivid characters and milieu, alongside Cosmo Jarvis’s sympathetic performance.
Read the full review →E
Empire
11 March 2020 · Ian Freer
65*
Freer finds the film uneven, saying it never balances character drama with gangster conventions, but still creates an effective mood. He particularly praises Cosmo Jarvis’s forceful performance and the tension created by the filmmaking and sound design.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
7 September 2019 · festival review · Wendy Ide
64*
The page identifies this as a Toronto review, but the critic’s verdict is inaccessible. No praise or complaint can be established from the visible text.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
30 July 2020
64*
The review text is unavailable, so its verdict cannot be determined. No specific praise or complaint can be verified from the accessible page.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
12 March 2020 · 3/3/3 · David Jenkins
60
Jenkins finds the film an intriguing character study hampered by an underpowered crime story. He especially praises the performances of Cosmo Jarvis and Niamh Algar.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★ · Karen Krizanovich
60
Krizanovich gives the film a three-star assessment, describing it as a well-crafted debut. She singles out Cosmo Jarvis’s portrayal of Arm, a reluctant enforcer struggling to be a good father.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
7 September 2019 · festival review · Keith Uhlich
50*
Uhlich finds the drama soporific and its stakes low, but says Cosmo Jarvis’s performance elevates it. He especially praises Jarvis’s compelling screen presence and emotionally taxing single-take scene.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
5 March 2020 · Peter Bradshaw
45*
Bradshaw finds the film powerful and engaging but ultimately trapped in a cul-de-sac of macho violence. He praises the forceful performances, especially Cosmo Jarvis’s fierce screen presence.
Read the full review →C
Collider
8 September 2019 · B+ · Perri Nemiroff
83
Nemiroff finds the film a compelling, tragic portrait of a man trapped between criminal loyalties and his desire to be a good father. She praises Cosmo Jarvis’s nuanced performance for making Douglas’s violence and warmth equally convincing.
Read the full review →F
Film Stories
17 April 2020 · Anna Wilczek
82*
The critic finds the film a terrific, moody directorial debut. She particularly praises Cosmo Jarvis’s nuanced performance and Barry Keoghan’s compelling presence.
Read the full review →The critic calls it a powerful, enthralling crime thriller with a hefty emotional punch. They praise Cosmo Jarvis’s compelling performance and the film’s tense, stylish build to a moving conclusion.
Read the full review →The critic finds the film a quiet, affecting character study amid its brutality. Cosmo Jarvis’s quietly gripping performance is singled out for bringing wounded humanity to Arm.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
6 March 2020 · ★★★½ · Rosie Fletcher
70
The review calls the film a confident, moving debut but finds its grim story ultimately unsatisfying and unpleasant to watch. It singles out Cosmo Jarvis’s sympathetic performance, especially a late phone-call scene, for praise.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
30 April 2020 · Amber Wilkinson
70*
Wilkinson finds the drama somewhat formulaic but compelling, with Cosmo Jarvis as its main draw. She especially praises his soulful, nuanced performance as a man struggling with the moral demands of gang life and fatherhood.
Read the full review →The review finds the film spare, savage and beautiful, though its story is flimsy and frustrating. It singles out Niamh Algar’s performance as the element that gives the film greater emotional depth.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
7 September 2019 · festival review
64*
The page is blocked, so the critic’s verdict cannot be determined. No praise or complaint from the review is visible.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate