Critics’ reviews

Clemency (2019)

21 reviews from 21 publications. Critics’ score 74: 14 positive, 6 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of Clemency

74
Positive
14
Mixed
6
Negative
1

Most critics respond warmly to Clemency as a sober, affecting examination of the human cost of capital punishment. Praise centres on Alfre Woodard’s restrained performance as the prison warden, particularly the small physical details that reveal the strain beneath her professional composure. Aldis Hodge also draws praise for his emotional depth. The favourable reviews value Chinonye Chukwu’s measured direction and the attention paid to how executions affect those involved.

Reservations concern pacing and how plainly the film delivers its themes, with even some admirers finding the middle section drawn out. The spread is wide: Variety finds the drama moving but argues that uncertainty about the prisoner’s guilt muddles its message, while Eye for Film objects to overly explicit storytelling. The Wrap offers the sharpest dissent, finding the restraint emotionally distancing and the central character underdeveloped, despite praising Hodge. The performances earn broader agreement than the storytelling.

IndieWire
28 January 2019 · A- · Eric Kohn
90

Kohn praises the film as a haunting, mature prison drama, while noting that its middle section drags. He singles out Alfre Woodard’s brilliant performance as the film’s central force.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
26 December 2019 · Justin Chang
90*

Chang praises the film as a gripping, powerfully bleak work of American realism. He singles out Alfre Woodard’s transfixing performance and the emotional depth she and Aldis Hodge bring to their brief exchanges.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
17 July 2020
90*

The critic finds the film a powerful, clear-eyed examination of America’s death penalty and the injustice it perpetuates. They single out Alfre Woodard’s restrained, phenomenal performance as the warden for praise.

Read the full review →
Empire
14 July 2020 · Pamela Hutchinson
85*

Hutchinson praises the film as a powerful, morally forceful drama about the human toll of executions. She singles out Alfre Woodard’s subtle, affecting performance and the film’s quiet, economical storytelling.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
28 January 2019 · festival review · David Rooney
85*

Rooney finds the film engrossing and affecting, though somewhat drawn out, and sees it as a measured advocacy drama. He especially praises Alfre Woodard’s restrained, deeply felt performance as the burdened prison warden.

Read the full review →
Vulture
17 January 2020 · Angelica Jade Bastién
85*

Bastién gives the film a strongly positive verdict, calling it an actors’ showcase and praising its emotional intelligence. She singles out Alfre Woodard’s finely detailed performance, especially the expressive work of her face and body.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
17 July 2020 · ★★★★ · Charlotte O'Sullivan
80

O'Sullivan finds the deliberately harrowing film ultimately elating and says its precise filmmaking offers hope. She praises Alfre Woodard's outstanding performance, while noting that Wendell Pierce's husband character feels too much like a type.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
16 July 2020 · 4/4/4 · Rógan Graham
80

The critic finds the drama moving and says its heavy experience is worth the investment. They single out Alfre Woodard’s performance and praise Chinonye Chukwu’s restrained direction.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Beth Webb
80

The critic calls the film both gut-wrenching and vital. They single out Alfre Woodard’s performance as a career-defining role.

Read the full review →
Time Out
15 July 2020 · ★★★★ · Phil de Semlyen
80

The critic calls the film excellent, praising its austere treatment of the human cost of the death penalty. Alfre Woodard’s performance is singled out as stunning.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
17 December 2019 · ★★★/4 · Chuck Bowen
75

Bowen finds the film a compelling, contradictory morality play, though its austere approach lacks some liveliness. He especially praises Alfre Woodard’s subtle performance and the scene where Wendell Pierce reads from Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
13 September 2019 · festival review · Benjamin Lee
75*

The critic finds the film bleakly effective, with only a distracting reliance on dream sequences as a notable flaw. Alfre Woodard’s nuanced, restrained performance is singled out as its greatest strength.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
festival review
64*

The page could not be accessed, so the critic’s verdict cannot be verified. Its praise or criticism of the film is likewise unavailable.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
25 December 2019
64*

The article body is inaccessible, so its verdict cannot be determined. No specific praise or criticism is available from the page.

Read the full review →
Variety
28 January 2019 · festival review · Amy Nicholson
55*

Nicholson finds the death-penalty drama moving but says its doubts about Anthony’s guilt muddle its message. She praises Alfre Woodard’s performance, especially the moments when Bernadine’s professional mask slips.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
2 January 2020 · Anthony Lane
45*

Lane finds the film’s performances strong but says its middle section loses energy and its central themes feel overburdened. He singles out the two execution scenes as the film’s most effective passages, especially Woodard’s final, anguished performance.

Read the full review →
NME
90*

The critic calls the film a tour de force and praises its emotionally charged complexity. Alfre Woodard’s precise, poised performance is singled out as magnificent.

Read the full review →
Paste
27 December 2019 · 8.0 · Andy Crump
83*

Crump finds the film a nuanced, powerful examination of capital punishment’s toll on everyone involved, while ultimately centering Anthony’s plight. He especially praises the scene between Bernadine and Anthony as she explains the execution drugs, highlighting Chukwu’s craft and the actors’ expressive performances.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
28 January 2019 · festival review
64*

The critic’s verdict and specific praise or criticism are unavailable because the page is blocked. The accessible text contains only an anti-crawler notice.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
8 April 2019 · Jeremy Mathews
50*

The critic finds the film weighed down by overly explicit storytelling despite the strength of its performances. Alfre Woodard’s performance as the prison warden is singled out as its greatest asset.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
23 December 2019
30*

TheWrap finds the film well-intentioned but emotionally hollow, with its restrained approach preventing it from resonating. It praises Aldis Hodge’s heartrending performance and the vivid depiction of the execution process, while faulting the underdeveloped central character.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate