The consensus on Constantine is mixed, with praise clustering around its Gothic atmosphere, inventive visual details and special effects. Even several less persuaded critics admire the imagery and the sense of supernatural unease. Performances draw more selective approval: Tilda Swinton’s Gabriel and Rachel Weisz receive praise, while Eye for Film also welcomes the chemistry between Weisz and Keanu Reeves. The recurring reservation is that the images offer more interest than the story or its religious ideas.
The reviews range from qualified enjoyment to outright rejection. Empire finds a wry pleasure despite weaknesses in the script and supporting characters; elsewhere, complaints centre on confusing exposition, thin substance and Reeves’s unconvincing performance. Time Out treats his wooden portrayal as a central problem, rather than a drawback the atmosphere can overcome. The New Yorker offers the sharpest dissent, regarding the use of Catholic doctrine and imagery as exploitative spectacle.
