The reviews are warmly positive, and the praise gathers around the same places. Most critics single out Raoul Coutard’s photography, with the opening camera movement praised in particular, and the long marital argument at the film’s centre, which several find emotionally exact. Brigitte Bardot’s performance draws notice for the fragility under the surface, and the film’s mixing of Homer, film-making and a failing marriage is generally read as a strength rather than a distraction.
The reservations are about how the film wears. The Guardian thinks it has dated and curdled, and Eye for Film finds it clever and enjoyable without being convinced it is a major work. The AV Club, though admiring, calls it hard to like and thinks the domestic argument slows things down. The spread is fairly narrow: nobody dismisses it, and even the mildest verdict finds plenty to enjoy.
