Most critics like Coriolanus, and the praise settles in the same two places: Ralph Fiennes as director, in his first film, and Fiennes as the general himself. The reviews credit him with making Shakespeare’s language sound natural amid tanks and automatic weapons, and with setting the play in a Balkan-style war zone, with rolling-news inserts, without the update feeling like a stunt. Vanessa Redgrave’s Volumnia is singled out almost everywhere, with Brian Cox and Gerard Butler close behind, and the combat scenes are widely called shattering.
The spread is narrow. No review is negative, and the two mixed notices still admire the acting. The reservations cluster around the handheld camerawork, which Slant Magazine finds a misstep and Time Out thinks falls short in the vérité action; The New Yorker finds the modern media touches forced, Variety struggles to follow the political manoeuvring, and Screen Daily notes second-act wordiness and an overlong finale.
A
The AV Club
19 January 2012 · A- · Keith Phipps
90
The critic commends the film as a brutal and bleak adaptation that uses a contemporary setting to accentuate Shakespeare's themes of politics, war, and class. It singles out Fiennes' intense performance as Coriolanus for capturing the character's emotional stuntedness and commitment to military honor.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
2 December 2011 · Betsy Sharkey
85*
Fiennes' ambitious directorial debut thrillingly updates the tragedy with operatic scale, gritty warfare, and standout performances from Redgrave, Cox, and others, making it memorable and prescient.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
15 February 2011 · Peter Bradshaw
85*
The critic calls Fiennes's directorial debut a triumph for reconfiguring the play as a study of modern warfare with news inserts. He singles out the film's clarity, intelligence, and shattering combat scenes along with careful narrative attention.
Read the full review →E
Empire
8 January 2012 · Angie Errigo
81*
The critic finds Fiennes on firm footing with this political thriller and praises its assured direction and timely themes. She singles out the contemporary resonance in modern dress and Balkan-style war zones, along with strong performances from Redgrave and Butler.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
17 February 2011 · festival review · Ray Bennett
80*
The critic praises Fiennes' directorial debut for turning the Shakespeare play into a modern, bloody action picture with tanks and automatic weapons while keeping the original language natural. It highlights strong performances, especially by Fiennes, Redgrave, Cox, and Butler, calling it a tough, violent, and moving tragedy.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
1 December 2011 · Manohla Dargis
80*
Fiennes delivers a thrilling performance as the title character in his directorial debut, bringing fierce intensity to the modernized Shakespearean tragedy set amid contemporary warfare and political intrigue.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
28 November 2011 · ★★★/4 · Nick Schager
75
The critic finds the Paul Greengrass-style handheld camerawork a misstep that fails to enhance the material, but praises the fidelity to Shakespeare's prose and the central performances, especially Redgrave's titanic Volumnia and Fiennes' fiery intensity, along with the enduring themes of class and duty.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
15 January 2012 · Anthony Lane
75*
Fiennes' intense, gory adaptation captures the play's drive and desperation through strong performances, particularly Redgrave as Volumnia, though some modern media elements feel forced.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
14 February 2011 · festival review · Lee Marshall
70*
Fiennes’s impressive debut vindicates the play as a complex character study full of contemporary relevance through its modern Balkan setting and news-channel framing, with strong casting and performances. The film has second-act wordiness and an overlong finale but remains a worthy, good-looking addition to Shakespeare adaptations.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
1 February 2012 · David Jays
70*
Fiennes’s bold modern adaptation makes a strong fist of the material with intelligent choices and a documentary-style atmosphere, though the astringent play stays somewhat at arm’s length. The critic highlights the intense performances, especially Redgrave’s adamantine mother and the homoerotic tension in combat scenes.
Read the full review →V
Variety
14 February 2011 · festival review · Peter Debruge
70*
Fiennes' bloody directorial debut updates the tragedy effectively in action sequences with strong visuals and cast, though political intrigue can be hard to follow.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
15 February 2011 · ★★★ · Trevor Johnston
60
This ferocious 21st-century update marks a committed directorial debut that keeps the themes relevant and witty despite the modernity; Fiennes attacks the role with vivid urgency while Redgrave and Cox deliver standout turns. The director falls short on some vérité action sequences but knows when to let the actors rip.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
1 December 2011 · B+ · The Playlist Staff
83
The critic calls it a remarkable directorial debut with standout performances from Fiennes, Redgrave, and others, plus effective use of film techniques for intimacy and visuals. It notes the challenging nature of the play itself, with performances and direction often outshining the material as a whole.
Read the full review →P
Paste
30 November 2011 · 8.9 · Annlee Ellingson
81*
Ralph Fiennes makes a bold directorial debut with this contemporary adaptation that strikes a delicate balance between Shakespeare’s iambic pentameter and an ultra-modern plot and setting. The critic singles out the gritty, documentary-style battle scenes that juxtapose realistic handheld camerawork with erudite monologues for special praise.
Read the full review →D
Digital Spy
20 January 2012 · Ben Rawson-Jones
80*
Fiennes' impressive directorial debut modernizes the tragedy with ferocious intensity and thematic potency, delivering a compelling character study through strong performances and effective handheld camerawork that creates documentary-like immediacy.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
17 October 2011 · ★★★½ · Owen Van Spall
70
The critic commends the strong performances, particularly Redgrave and Cox, the stripped-down script that keeps pacing tight, and the effective modern visuals and editing that make the themes accessible. The modern setting ultimately enhances rather than obscures the study of power and authority.
Read the full review →H
HeyUGuys
17 January 2012 · ★★★½ · Adam Lowes
70
The critic praises the powerhouse performances, especially Fiennes and Redgrave, and the gritty cinematography that adds intimacy and urgency. It notes the film is watchable but unlikely to rank among the best Shakespeare adaptations.
Read the full review →S
The Skinny
1 June 2012 · ★★★ · Nicola Balkind
60
Fiennes' ambitious directorial debut is a grim, gritty modern adaptation of the lesser-known Shakespeare play, using news-style inserts to draw contemporary parallels while delivering measured language amid austere visuals.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate