Most critics like it, and many like it a great deal. The reviews describe a murder mystery that turns out to be a love story, and the praise gathers in two places: Park Chan-wook’s direction, particularly the inventiveness of his compositions and the precision of the editing, and Tang Wei’s performance as the suspect, which several critics name as the thing that makes an enigmatic character worth following. Her chemistry with Park Hae-il comes up nearly as often.
The reservations are about the second half. Several critics find the middle baggy or the final third drifting, and some feel the plot’s technology and twists grow overcomplicated. The spread is narrow, with no outright negative reviews, but a few dissent: Slant finds the thriller so convoluted that the romance goes inert, Vulture finds it fragmentary and emotionally distant despite a haunting finale, and Deadline faults the pacing and an unfeeling conclusion. Even they praise Tang Wei.
I
IndieWire
23 May 2022 · A- · David Ehrlich
90
Ehrlich calls it an unexpectedly romantic procedural whose restrained approach still delivers a deeply affecting finale. He praises Park’s precise editing and staging, while noting that the technology-driven plot and complicated third act can feel overworked.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
13 October 2022 · Justin Chang
90*
Chang finds the film an invigorating, despairing love story and a luxuriant romantic noir. He especially praises Park’s inventive visual style and Park Hae-il and Tang Wei’s performances.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
13 October 2022 · A- · Mark Keizer
90
Keizer praises the film as an intricate, restrained, and probing drama, though its tragic ending feels more intellectual than emotional. He singles out Park’s visual inventiveness and the leads’ finely calibrated chemistry.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
23 May 2022 · festival review · Peter Bradshaw
90*
Bradshaw gives the film a strongly positive verdict, calling it gorgeously made and gripping. He particularly praises Tang Wei’s magnificent performance and the film’s suspenseful, consistently surprising storytelling.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
23 May 2022 · festival review · David Rooney
90*
Rooney finds the film intoxicating and praises Park as a world-class artist at the top of his game. He singles out the leads’ smoldering chemistry and the film’s ravishing visuals, especially its striking compositions.
Read the full review →E
Empire
19 October 2022 · Nick de Semlyen
85*
The critic calls it a tremendous, sophisticated erotic thriller and praises Park’s inventive visual storytelling. The middle section occasionally feels baggy, but Tang Wei’s mesmerizing performance and the film’s precise camerawork stand out.
Read the full review →i
The i Paper
21 October 2022 · Christina Newland
85*
Newland praises the film as absorbing, enigmatic and masterful, with a hypnotic rhythm. She singles out Park’s precise editing and his ability to make tiny visual details feel charged with meaning.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
7 October 2022 · Anthony Lane
85*
Lane finds the film an astonishing and persuasive romance, whose elaborate mystery ultimately brushes against tragedy. He praises the visual wit and forensic precision of Park’s imagery.
Read the full review →V
Variety
23 May 2022 · Critics Pick · Jessica Kiang
85*
The review calls the film a masterful, dazzling love story wrapped in a mischievous murder mystery. It especially praises the expressive camerawork and the leads’ subtle, compelling chemistry.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
19 October 2022 · 5/4/5 · Hannah Strong
80
Strong presents the film as an intimate, sumptuous romance whose mystery keeps its emotional cards close. She particularly praises Tang Wei’s magnetic performance as Seo-rae and the film’s morally complex characters.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★★ · Max Copeman
80
Copeman finds the mystery exquisitely made and Hitchcockian in spirit. He especially praises Tang Wei's performance for its depth and intrigue.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
24 May 2022 · ★★★★ · Phil de Semlyen
80
The review finds the film a woozily seductive murder mystery. It singles out Park Chan-wook’s slowed-down, spellbinding approach for praise.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
23 May 2022 · ★★★★ · Neil Smith
80
The critic finds the film an intoxicating, achingly romantic neo-noir, though its second half loses momentum and it feels too long. They single out the elegant visuals, evocative score, and sophisticated costumes for praise.
Read the full review →F
Film Comment
festival review · Imogen Sara Smith
70*
The critic presents the film as a notably romantic entry in Park Chan-wook’s filmography. The standfirst singles out its epic detective story and romantic emphasis.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
23 May 2022 · festival review · Wendy Ide
70*
The standfirst presents the film as a seductive neo-noir. It singles out the blurred lines between detective and suspect as central to its appeal.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
13 October 2022
70*
The critic finds the film’s image-rich, ambiguous approach largely successful, despite a drifting final third. Tang Wei’s magnetic performance is singled out for making an enigmatic character compelling.
Read the full review →The page could not be accessed, so the critic’s verdict is unavailable. Its praise or complaints cannot be determined from the provided content.
Read the full review →The page could not be accessed, so the critic’s verdict is unavailable. No specific praise or criticism can be verified from the supplied text.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
11 September 2022 · ★★½/4 · Chuck Bowen
62
Bowen finds the thriller pointlessly overcomplicated, leaving its emotional story inert. He praises the beauty of a beachside disappearance, though he says the film does little to make its tragedy meaningful.
Read the full review →V
Vulture
22 October 2022 · Bilge Ebiri
45*
Ebiri finds the film fragmentary and emotionally distancing, though its haunting finale nearly saves it. He especially praises Tang Wei’s layered, captivating performance.
Read the full review →S
The Skinny
18 October 2022 · ★★★★★ · Ross McIndoe
100
The review praises the film as a consistently accomplished work of filmmaking. It singles out Park Chan-wook’s visual inventiveness and the sensual chemistry between the two leads.
Read the full review →C
Collider
21 September 2022 · B+ · Ross Bonaime
83
Bonaime praises the film as an accomplished blend of romance and mystery. He especially singles out Park Hae-il and Tang Wei for conveying powerful feelings through quiet, restrained performances.
Read the full review →R
The Ringer
13 October 2022 · Adam Nayman
82*
Nayman finds the film a controlled, absorbing high point in Park Chan-wook’s later work. He praises how its restrained visual style serves the story’s uneasy blend of mystery and romance.
Read the full review →C
Consequence
30 September 2022 · festival review · Clint Worthington
80*
Worthington finds the film a captivating, inventive take on a romantic crime thriller. He especially praises Park’s inventive camera work and Tang Wei’s precise performance.
Read the full review →P
Polygon
14 October 2022 · Tasha Robinson
80*
Robinson finds the film a sophisticated, satisfying portrait of obsession and regret, despite its less dynamic procedural story. She especially praises how its quiet character details gradually reveal the leads’ feelings and deepen their relationship.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
festival review
79*
The headline presents the film as an elusive, alluring romance. It highlights Park Chan-wook’s conjuring of seductive illusions.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
10 December 2022 · Jennie Kermode
78*
The critic finds the film difficult but ultimately rewarding, with an ending that lingers in the mind. She praises its intricate psychological romance and the way desire emerges through the characters’ intellectual conflict.
Read the full review →P
Paste
13 October 2022 · 7.3/10 · Brianna Zigler
73
The critic calls it an extravagant, hopelessly romantic thriller, though not Park Chan-wook’s best work or a masterpiece. She praises its lavish visual style and yearning romance, while noting that the excess can overwhelm the film and leave it feeling as if something is missing.
Read the full review →/
/Film
24 May 2022 · 7/10 · Rafael Motamayor
70
The critic finds the film fascinating and exquisitely directed, though less surprising and innovative than Park Chan-wook’s earlier work. They praise the palpable chemistry between the leads and the director’s skill at building tension through staging and visual composition.
Read the full review →The critic finds the film intriguing and addictive, though some twists do not strengthen its narrative. They particularly praise its stunning, inventive cinematography.
Read the full review →W
The Wrap
13 October 2022 · festival review
70*
The critic finds the film gorgeous and richly dramatic, though at times confounding and emotionally uneven. They praise Park’s intricate, visually striking filmmaking and its ability to make ordinary settings feel alluring.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
23 May 2022 · festival review · Valerie Complex
50*
The critic finds the film uneven but ultimately recommends it, largely for its stellar first half. She praises Tang Wei’s performance and the leads’ subtle, compelling dynamic, while faulting the latter half’s pacing and emotionless conclusion.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate