The reviews lean cautiously favourable, though agreement is stronger on the film’s dark humour and formal invention than on its merits as a whole. Praise centres on the shifts between Harry’s real and fictional lives, the clarity of the complicated storytelling and the willingness to leave its protagonist unredeemed. The Independent particularly admires the brisk storytelling, inventive editing and sharp ensemble scenes. Supporters find the comedy painfully self-critical, with several praising its ability to make uncomfortable material funny.
The spread is wide, and the treatment of women is a dividing point. Empire finds laughs but is disturbed by Allen’s scathing treatment of women and his own neuroses. The AV Club goes much further, finding sexist characterisation, self-indulgence and too few laughs to compensate. Elsewhere, reservations concern familiarity and abrasiveness: qualities that admirers accept as part of the film’s risk-taking, rather than reasons to dismiss it.
