Most critics lean positive on El Topo, with praise centring on its startling imagery and dense, conflicting symbols. The favourable reviews find its difficulty part of the appeal: the private mythology can be bewildering, but it also gives the film an immersive force. Jodorowsky’s direction and performance draw praise for their invention and hypnotic energy, while the desert imagery offers something concrete to admire amid the allegory.
The divide concerns how much that fascination compensates for obscurity and self-indulgence. Eye for Film acknowledges dated aspects but finds intelligence in the handling of clashing symbols; The Guardian is less persuaded by the film’s reputation, though its symbolism and disturbing cult-horror scenes still exert a pull. The spread runs from enthusiasm to qualified disappointment, with no wholly negative assessments in the supplied tally. Even the warmer accounts leave room for bewilderment.
