Critics’ reviews

El Topo (1970)

9 reviews from 9 publications. Critics’ score 68: 5 positive, 4 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of El Topo

68
Positive
5
Mixed
4
Negative
0

Most critics lean positive on El Topo, with praise centring on its startling imagery and dense, conflicting symbols. The favourable reviews find its difficulty part of the appeal: the private mythology can be bewildering, but it also gives the film an immersive force. Jodorowsky’s direction and performance draw praise for their invention and hypnotic energy, while the desert imagery offers something concrete to admire amid the allegory.

The divide concerns how much that fascination compensates for obscurity and self-indulgence. Eye for Film acknowledges dated aspects but finds intelligence in the handling of clashing symbols; The Guardian is less persuaded by the film’s reputation, though its symbolism and disturbing cult-horror scenes still exert a pull. The spread runs from enthusiasm to qualified disappointment, with no wholly negative assessments in the supplied tally. Even the warmer accounts leave room for bewilderment.

Empire
30 March 2007 · David Parkinson
80*

The critic praises the film as a vital, visionary cult classic, despite its difficulty. He singles out its dense allegory and imagery for continuing to challenge and intrigue.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
11 December 2006 · ★★★/4 · Fernando F. Croce
75

Croce sees the film as a delirious, inscrutable work whose impact depends on whether its private mythology connects with the viewer. He praises its immersive force and its memorable, often startling imagery.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
70*

The page is identified as a Great Movies review, but its verdict cannot be determined from the blocked content. No praised or criticized element is available to report.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
9 January 2020 · Philip Strick
70*

Strick finds the film absurd and bewildering, but ultimately energetic and inventive. He singles out Jodorowsky’s inventive direction and hypnotic performance for praise.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
20 November 1971 · Pauline Kael
66*

The archive identifies this as Pauline Kael’s review of “El Topo,” but the review itself is unavailable here. The accessible listing does not reveal her verdict or what she singles out for praise or complaint.

Read the full review →
Time Out
3 April 2007 · Ben Walters
65*

The available description notes the film’s formidable reputation as a seminal midnight movie, but does not reveal the critic’s verdict. No specific element is singled out for praise or complaint in the accessible text.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
23 May 1971
63*

The headline frames the article as questioning whether El Topo is a con. The blocked page provides no further information about the critic’s verdict or what they praise or criticize.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
9 January 2020 · Peter Bradshaw
45*

Bradshaw finds the film less impressive than its legendary reputation, though its opaque symbolism still fascinates. He especially singles out the desert imagery and the disturbing cult-horror scenes.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
31 March 2007 · Anton Bitel
80*

Bitel calls the film one of Jodorowsky’s finest, despite its dated aspects and self-indulgence. He praises its haunting imagery and the intelligence with which it juggles clashing symbols.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate