Critics’ reviews

Encanto (2021)

23 reviews from 23 publications. Critics’ score 80: 22 positive, 0 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of Encanto

80
Positive
22
Mixed
0
Negative
1

Most critics warmly welcome Encanto as an animated musical whose close attention to family expectations gives its magic emotional weight. Praise clusters around the expressive animation, the Colombian setting and cultural detail, and the Madrigal house as a character in its own right. Lin-Manuel Miranda’s songs are widely admired for their energy and storytelling, while Mirabel’s ordinary status within an extraordinary family gives the reviews a sympathetic heroine to rally round.

Reservations concern familiar storytelling and the tendency to tidy away complicated family hurts. The range of opinion is wide, though only one of the 23 reviews is negative. RogerEbert.com finds some songs forgettable and the narrative prone to meandering; /Film considers the storytelling too formulaic. The Guardian is the clear dissenter, finding little magic in the film and arguing that its messages about the characters’ gifts contradict one another.

The Independent
22 November 2021 · ★★★★/4 · Mark Kennedy
100

The critic calls it a charming animated musical that flips the typical script by making the ordinary weird in a magical Colombian family. They single out the expressive visuals, house-as-character, and Miranda songs for praise.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
15 November 2021 · David Rooney
91*

The critic calls it an absolute charmer, praising the purity of its storytelling, stunning visuals, and the buoyant original songs by Lin-Manuel Miranda that blend traditional musical theater with Colombian music.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
23 November 2021 · Critic’s Pick · Maya Phillips
91*

The critic praises the film as brilliant Disney animation with stunning visuals, a beautifully composed story focused on family dynamics, and spellbinding songs, highlighting its respect for Latino culture.

Read the full review →
Vulture
24 November 2021
91*

The critic deems it the best Disney animated film since Frozen, praising its visual and musical strategies that underscore a nuanced tale of self-doubt, family expectations, and maintaining a façade, which becomes enormously moving.

Read the full review →
Empire
15 November 2021 · Ben Travis
85*

The critic praises the vibrant visuals, stellar songs, and story with real heart as another Disney banger. They single out the intimate family story, Miranda's melodies, and the emotional finale for praise.

Read the full review →
Total Film
16 November 2021
85*

The critic calls it high-tier modern Disney that recasts the studio formula in fresh, dazzling shapes. They single out the endearing heroine, Colombia-set setting, and especially Lin-Manuel Miranda's songs for praise.

Read the full review →
Variety
15 November 2021 · Critics Pick · Owen Gleiberman
85*

The critic calls it a lively, lovely, lush animated musical fairy tale with vibrant animation and infectious songs by Lin-Manuel Miranda that keep the film bopping, noting its girl-power themes and emotional depth.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
23 November 2021 · Katie Walsh
80*

The critic describes it as a rousing and compassionate animated musical with vibrant animation and a fast-paced script rooted in lessons about self-worth, praising its empathetic charm and potential for healing.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
15 November 2021 · ★★★★ · Patrick Cremona
80

The critic describes it as a vibrant and rousing exploration of family and Colombian culture and praises the bright, lively animation with memorable characters and the anthropomorphised Madrigal home.

Read the full review →
The i Paper
25 November 2021 · Francesca Steele
80*

The critic describes it as a spectacular yet intimate coming-of-age fable celebrating ordinariness and everyday miracles in a Colombian magical family. They single out the best soundtrack since Frozen and the lack of a villain for praise.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
25 November 2021 · ★★★★ · Robbie Collin
80

The critic calls it an out-and-out delight and a lusciously rendered swashbuckling adventure with dazzling animation, a sentient house, and a shrewdly introspective story about a young woman who feels surplus to requirements, boosted by Lin-Manuel Miranda's Latin and hip-hop-flavoured songs.

Read the full review →
Time Out
26 November 2021 · ★★★★ · Whelan Barzey
80

The critic calls it a fun, boisterous and sassy magical realistic tale and praises the animation for rendering luscious flowers, hair textures and skin tones as a genuine love letter to the diversity of Latin America.

Read the full review →
The Times
25 November 2021 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher
78*

The critic praises it as a spectacular all-singing all-dancing Disney cartoon with a muscular sense of its own identity that addresses superhero tropes and the weight of family expectations and status in a Colombian setting, though it ends with a somewhat compromised happy ending.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
15 November 2021
77*

The review praises its clever use of magical realism that brings a vibrant, distinctly South American flavor and conveys that even in the best families it takes work to stay together, though the resolution is wrapped up too quickly and cleanly.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
15 November 2021
75*

The critic calls it an appealing animated film that finds fresh ways to tell a story about characters with powers and praises the heartfelt message about coming to terms with trauma, which yields intensely moving results when the directors focus on underlying emotions.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
15 November 2021 · B- · Kristen Lopez
70

The review describes it as a beautiful but trite lavish animated musical that feels emotionally wrought about family hurts and how 'normal' can be a four-letter word, though the story tries too hard to wrap nuance in a tidy bow.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
24 November 2021 · Monica Castillo
70*

The critic finds the film a charming animated musical about family and self-worth despite some meandering and forgettable songs, praising its animation, design, voice cast, and cultural nods to Colombia.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
15 November 2021
30*

The critic finds the film a blandly frictionless Disney fairytale that misses the magic, hampered by contradictory messages about its characters' gifts and a lack of sparkle despite nice moments and sweet show tunes by Lin-Manuel Miranda.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
24 November 2021 · ★★★★★ · Emily Breen
100

The review calls Encanto a joy with dazzling animation and a colourful soundtrack by Lin-Manuel Miranda, highlighting Mirabel as an engaging heroine and the film's delicate handling of peril leading to happy tears.

Read the full review →
Collider
15 November 2021 · A- · Matt Goldberg
90

The critic calls Encanto a heartwarming celebration of family that stands out from recent Disney Animation films by focusing entirely on familial relationships and expectations rather than using family as mere backdrop. They single out the catchy, original songs by Lin-Manuel Miranda and the gorgeous animation for praise, while noting the story's emphasis that Mirabel does not need a superpower to be special.

Read the full review →
Polygon
15 November 2021 · Petrana Radulovic
90*

The critic praises Encanto as a musical masterpiece and one of the most emotionally compelling films of Disney’s Revival Era, highlighting its tight focus on complex family dynamics, relatable themes of legacy and expectations, and effective use of music and animation to explore them without relying on a traditional villain. They single out the story’s grounded, inward-looking approach to family relationships and the infectious, storytelling-driven songs.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
24 November 2021 · ★★★★ · Andrew Robertson
80

The critic finds the film breezy, bright, and brilliant, praising its catchy songs, dazzling animation, and charming take on family dynamics and magical realism in a Colombian setting.

Read the full review →
/Film
15 November 2021 · 7/10 · Josh Spiegel
70

The critic describes it as a likable and charming Disney film with beautiful animation and strong cultural elements, but notes it stays formulaic and does not push storytelling limits far enough.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate