Enchanted (2007)

Kermode finds the film a delightful, refreshing family fantasy that appeals across ages. He especially praises Amy Adams for making Giselle’s innocence charming rather than irritatingly cute.

Barber finds the film wholesome, mischievous and enchanting, calling it Disney’s best cartoon in years. He especially praises Amy Adams’s performance as Giselle, whose straight-faced naivety wins laughs and sympathy.

McCarthy finds the film an unusually charming, broadly appealing musical that lives up to its title. He especially praises Amy Adams’s magnetic performance, which gives Giselle’s transformation emotional depth and comic sparkle.

Richards finds the film a silly, retro blast that works especially well for fairy-tale fans. He singles out Amy Adams’s spirited comic performance as one of the year’s best.

The critic suggests the film succeeds where the Shrek sequel disappointed. Amy Adams is singled out as Giselle in the story’s shift from animation to live action.

The review praises the film as an amusing parody of Disney’s own stories. It singles out the playful blend of classic fairy-tale material for praise.

Simon finds the film a genial, pleasantly told family comedy that leaves a smile. He especially praises Amy Adams’s radiant, engaging performance as Giselle.

The review calls the film a safe, enjoyable family outing, though not a spectacular one. It singles out Amy Adams’s energetic, dimensional performance as the film’s heart and soul.

Schager finds the film energetic but ultimately regressive in its treatment of women. He praises the humor of Giselle cleaning Robert’s apartment with the help of city animals.

Honeycutt finds the film clever in moments but ultimately grating and heavy-handed. He praises Amy Adams for making Giselle’s transition from cartoon to live action believable, while faulting the film for leaving its premise largely unexplored.

Kermode finds the film delightful and says its simple premise is executed with charm. She especially praises the leads’ innocent performances and the film’s ability to entertain without irony.

Brew warmly recommends the film and its Blu-ray presentation, while noting the villain is underused. He singles out Amy Adams’s performance as the film’s standout strength.

The critic finds Enchanted an entertaining family film, though too self-conscious to match classic Disney. Amy Adams’s committed, energetic performance as Giselle is singled out for praise, while the ending’s overt self-reference and bathroom humor draw complaints.