Most critics like Enemy of the State as a fast, noisy chase thriller and do not ask much more of it. Six of the nine reviews are positive, and the praise clusters in two places: Tony Scott’s direction, which several reviewers credit with keeping the paranoia moving at a sprint, and the two leads. Will Smith is found charismatic and funny, and Gene Hackman’s tense, dry presence is singled out again and again, even by critics who are otherwise unimpressed.
The reservations are about the plot rather than the people. More than one review notes that the conspiracy story is borrowed, and Variety finds it short on the political urgency and emotional weight of the thrillers it imitates. The spread is wide: the lone negative notice, from The AV Club, calls the film competent but formulaic, with a slow opening and surveillance scenes that fail to grip.
