Critics’ reviews

Enemy of the State (1998)

9 reviews from 9 publications. Critics’ score 69: 6 positive, 2 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of Enemy of the State

69
Positive
6
Mixed
2
Negative
1

Most critics like Enemy of the State as a fast, noisy chase thriller and do not ask much more of it. Six of the nine reviews are positive, and the praise clusters in two places: Tony Scott’s direction, which several reviewers credit with keeping the paranoia moving at a sprint, and the two leads. Will Smith is found charismatic and funny, and Gene Hackman’s tense, dry presence is singled out again and again, even by critics who are otherwise unimpressed.

The reservations are about the plot rather than the people. More than one review notes that the conspiracy story is borrowed, and Variety finds it short on the political urgency and emotional weight of the thrillers it imitates. The spread is wide: the lone negative notice, from The AV Club, calls the film competent but formulaic, with a slow opening and surveillance scenes that fail to grip.

Empire
1 January 2000 · Andrew Collins
80*

The critic calls the film great fun, praising its stylish visual approach and sustained paranoid pace. He also singles out Gene Hackman and the offbeat supporting cast for keeping the film compelling.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Alan Jones
80

The review calls the thriller cracking, with plenty of edge and appeal. It praises Tony Scott’s direction and Will Smith’s central performance.

Read the full review →
Total Film
26 December 1998 · ★★★★ · Total Film
80

The review calls it an immensely satisfying, fast-moving chase movie despite its unoriginal plot. It praises the performances of Will Smith and Gene Hackman, along with Tony Scott’s visual flair.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
20 November 1998 · ★★★/4 · Roger Ebert
75

Ebert considers it an entertaining, energetic surveillance thriller. He singles out the film’s fast-paced direction and elaborate use of surveillance technology for praise.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
20 November 1998 · Janet Maslin
70*

Maslin gives the film a generally positive verdict as a lively thriller. She singles out its energetic, high-tech suspense as a strength.

Read the full review →
Time Out
· NB
64*

The page identifies itself as a film review, but its review text is unavailable here. No critical verdict or specific praise or complaint can be established from the accessible material.

Read the full review →
Variety
15 November 1998 · Emanuel Levy
60*

Levy finds the film sporadically entertaining but lacking the political urgency and emotional resonance of classic conspiracy thrillers. He praises the performances, particularly Will Smith’s leading turn and Gene Hackman’s tense, humorous presence, while faulting the limited psychological depth.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
29 March 2002 · Keith Phipps
35*

Phipps finds the thriller competent but underwhelming, arguing it brings little new to the paranoid-conspiracy formula. He praises Gene Hackman’s performance and the likable lead and supporting actors, while criticizing the slow start and surveillance scenes.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
19 January 2001 · Angus Wolfe Murray
78*

The critic finds it an entertaining, fast-paced thriller that will keep viewers engaged. He particularly praises Will Smith’s charismatic, humorous action-hero performance and Tony Scott’s steady handling of the chase-and-conspiracy story.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate