Most critics find Gail Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass an enjoyably silly comedy, with praise clustering around its rapid-fire jokes and committed cast. Zoey Deutch is the clearest point of agreement: even some less enthusiastic reviews credit her sunny, spirited performance with keeping the absurdity afloat. John Slattery’s self-mocking turn also draws repeated praise. Supporters enjoy the mixture of warmth and vulgarity, and the willingness to keep pushing a ridiculous gag.
The spread is wide, however, and those prolonged jokes help explain the divide. Vulture finds that shared laughter in a cinema makes them funnier; The AV Club sees weak jokes, an unwieldy ensemble and a drawn-out subplot. Between those positions, reservations centre on uneven pacing, thin characterisation and a scattershot story. Even several favourable reviews concede that jokes miss or the film feels slight. The consensus favours the laughs, without agreeing on how much slack they earn.
