The reviews are split, and almost all of them agree on one thing: Robin Williams. The praise clusters on his improvised radio broadcasts, the rapid-fire impressions and the energy they lend a comedy most critics find funny in bursts. Even the harsher notices call the performance a virtuoso one. Variety also finds room for Bruno Kirby’s comic moments among the supporting cast.
They part on everything around him. The most common reservation is that the film falters when it turns serious: several critics find the later stretches clumsy, the script thin and the characters flat. The spread is wide, from warm approval at The Hollywood Reporter to outright dismissal. The AV Club goes furthest, finding the manic radio routines themselves the problem and preferring the supporting cast’s quieter exchanges with their officers, while Time Out judges the whole idea thin and bathetic despite the performance.
