Critics’ reviews

I Am Not a Witch (2017)

16 reviews from 16 publications. Critics’ score 76: 15 positive, 0 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of I Am Not a Witch

76
Positive
15
Mixed
0
Negative
1
The AV Club
7 September 2018 · A- · Katie Rife
90

Rife praises the film as a spellbinding, bone-dry satire, though its final third becomes repetitive. She singles out Maggie Mulubwa’s restrained performance and Nyoni’s bold, formally ambitious direction.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
3 September 2018 · ★★★½/4 · Pat Brown
88

The review praises the film’s deft balance of comedy and tragedy while emphasizing its critique of women’s exploitation. It singles out Maggie Mulubwa’s restrained performance as key to making Shula an empathetic figure.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
13 September 2018 · Kenneth Turan
82*

Turan praises the film as an audacious, smart, and savage satire with a dramatically involving story. He singles out Rungano Nyoni’s assured direction and the strong performance by young star Maggie Mulubwa.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
7 November 2017 · ★★★★ · Charlotte O'Sullivan
80

O’Sullivan finds the film gripping and buoyant despite a weak performance from the government official. She especially praises Maggie Mulubwa’s restrained portrayal and the witches’ vivid presence.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
19 October 2017 · 4/4/3 · Natalie Wardle
80

Wardle finds the film exhilarating and humorous, but says its sparse storytelling leaves viewers adrift near the end. She praises its striking visual compositions and costume design.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · David Parkinson
80

The review is positive, praising the film’s droll satire and its exposure of clashes between tradition and progress in modern Zambia. It also notes a sombre denunciation behind the comedy.

Read the full review →
Time Out
17 October 2017 · ★★★★ · Anna Smith
80

Smith presents the film as a sharp-edged, startling fable about Zambian society. She praises its magical-realist approach to gender and superstition, seen through a young orphan’s eyes.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
25 May 2017 · festival review · Stephen Dalton
75*

Dalton finds the film a hugely charming, spellbinding debut, while noting that its elliptical approach can make the story incoherent. He praises its striking visual style and inventive use of music.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
75*

The capsule presents Nyoni’s film as confrontational yet empathetic, with a largely positive verdict. It praises the powerful symbolic images Nyoni draws from the oppressive setting.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
6 September 2018 · Jeannette Catsoulis
75*

Catsoulis gives the film a positive verdict as a darkly comic, unsettling satire. She singles out its sharp treatment of the persecution and control of women.

Read the full review →
Total Film
26 May 2017 · festival review · Jamie Graham
75*

Graham finds the debut a fiercely original satire that rewards viewers willing to embrace its arthouse pace. He praises its striking imagery and deadpan humour, while noting that some satire feels scattershot and heavy-handed.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
26 May 2017 · festival review · Wendy Ide
70*

The critic presents the film as an arresting debut. She singles out its setting in and around Lusaka, Zambia.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
25 May 2017 · festival review · Gwilym Mumford
70*

The critic finds the film an original, charming satire, though its languid pacing and unclear storytelling sometimes frustrate. They single out Henry BJ Phiri’s performance as the officious, incompetent official for particular praise.

Read the full review →
Variety
27 May 2017 · festival review · Jessica Kiang
70*

Kiang finds the debut intriguing and invigorating, though at times too chaotic and difficult to follow. She especially praises David Gallego’s cinematography and its exploration of the film’s white streamers.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
13 January 2018 · Amber Wilkinson
85*

Wilkinson finds the film sharply funny and emotionally affecting in its satirical critique of sexual politics. She particularly praises the bobbins as a fairy-tale-like metaphor that becomes sinister on reflection.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
· Daniel Goodwin
35*

Goodwin finds the film absorbing but flawed, arguing its satire weakens its treatment of serious social issues. He praises Margaret Mulubwa’s performance and David Gallego’s cinematography.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate