Ice Age: The Meltdown (2006)

McCarthy calls the sequel an entirely serviceable follow-up that should entertain children and amuse parents. He praises its vibrant CGI, the returning voice cast’s sly performances, and Scrat’s comic misadventures.

Westbrook finds it a decent, charming sequel, though its story is weaker than the original. She praises the superb animation and Scrat’s increasingly hilarious acorn quest.

Wilmington considers the sequel a good movie, especially for children, but says its premise weakens the humor and makes it feel more like an anonymous franchise film. He praises Scrat’s acorn-chasing gags and John Leguizamo’s voice performance, while noting that the banter is weaker than in the original.

Mackie finds the sequel jolly, but less inventive and memorable than its predecessor. He praises Scrat’s comic interludes and Queen Latifah’s better-written role.

The page is inaccessible, so the critic’s verdict cannot be confirmed. No specific praise or complaint is available in the provided text.

The page identifies this as a review, but the critic’s verdict cannot be established from the available text. The truncated standfirst mentions Roadrunner cartoons and computer-animated works, without revealing what the critic singles out about this film.

Robinson finds the sequel thinly plotted and more like a collection of animated shorts than a coherent movie. She praises the vultures’ choreographed performance of “Food, Glorious Food” as a memorable highlight.

Hind finds the sequel pleasant and funny but ultimately lacking the kick to feel special. He praises the squirrel’s physical comedy as its main set piece.

Wilkinson finds the sequel entertaining in spots but ultimately disappointing and less cool than it should be. She particularly faults its disjointed plot and the lack of a credible threat.