Critics’ reviews

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008)

16 reviews from 16 publications. Critics’ score 60: 8 positive, 4 mixed, 4 negative.

Back to our review of Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull

60
Positive
8
Mixed
4
Negative
4

Most critics find it an acceptable return rather than a great one: eight of sixteen come down positive, and the praise clusters in the same places. Ford’s weary charm carries it, LaBeouf is a welcome sidekick, and Cate Blanchett’s villain is singled out more often than any set piece. Several reviews admire the opening stretch, with the early chase and the fridge scene mentioned as Spielberg at his most confident, and the practical stunt work is generally preferred to what follows.

The reservations gather in the second half. Once the story reaches the jungle, critics complain of convoluted plotting, heavier computer effects and a supernatural finale that even friendly reviews call hokum. The spread is wide: Den of Geek calls it a triumph, while The Guardian finds the revival pointless and The Hollywood Reporter a wearying onslaught that swamps story and character. A few also note the Russian villains never frighten the way the Nazis did.

Radio Times
★★★★ · Andrew Collins
80

The film delivers exhausting but enjoyable Saturday matinée thrills with chases, giant ants, secret passageways and aliens. It is hard to dislike thanks to Ford's weary charm, LaBeouf as the new sidekick and an emphasis on old-school stuntwork.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
18 May 2008
75*

The old magic still works in this fond reunion with an old friend that will not disappoint fans or new audiences as a summer blockbuster. It improves greatly once the treasure hunt and action sequences begin, with strong performances from Ford, LaBeouf and Allen balancing the spectacle.

Read the full review →
Empire
19 May 2008 · Damon Wise
70*

The critic calls it a minor triumph plucked from the jaws of disappointment, a real Indy movie that preserves the character's intelligence, urbanity and kick-arse cool while delivering slick fun action beats.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
19 May 2008 · festival review · Kenneth Turan
70*

The film avoids anticlimax and is entertaining in its own right thanks to Spielberg's skilled handling of stunts and effects, making it one of the better entries in the series even if not as iconic as Raiders. Supporting players like Blanchett shine amid solid action set pieces.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
22 May 2008 · B- · Scott Tobias
70

The review notes that while Spielberg orchestrates robust silliness with visual panache, the film fails to stick the landing after a strong start. The fun dissipates into noisy supernatural hokum as the story becomes overstuffed and labored.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
22 May 2008 · festival review · Manohla Dargis
70*

The film is a boomer-friendly reunion adventure that keeps the mood light and PG-13 friendly while delivering familiar thrills with Harrison Ford returning as Indy. It serves up reunion energy but notes some softening in the series' edge compared to earlier entries.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
· Sukhdev Sandhu
60*

The first 40 minutes are lean, delightful and terrifically handled with a brilliant fridge scene and exciting chase, but the film veers off course in the jungle with overly complicated plotting. Harrison Ford is fine, if a little stiff, and the script acknowledges his age while positioning a potential successor.

Read the full review →
Time Out
18 May 2008 · ★★★ · Dave Calhoun
60

The film is an acceptable but minor thrill ride that lacks the punch and pace of the earlier entries, relying too much on spectacle and CGI rather than human stunts. It works as passable nostalgia and old-fashioned action-adventure but the sentimental ending feels excessive.

Read the full review →
Total Film
23 May 2008
60*

It is neither the disaster some predicted nor the triumph others may claim; the new Russian villains do not convey the universal fear of the Nazis and the plotting is so-so, but Shia LaBeouf sails through the thrills and Ford can still crack the whip.

Read the full review →
The Times
25 May 2008
55*

It is an entertaining if uninspired film that delivers what fans expect from the familiar formula of exposition and action, though it lacks a heroic moment that brings everything together perfectly. The cold war premise is treated as absurd as the film itself, but the execution feels formulaic.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
26 May 2008 · David Denby
40*

Reviving the series after 19 years was a mistake, as the blend of comedy and action is mostly gone, leaving stretches flat and dull despite a few dazzling sequences and strong turns like Cate Blanchett. Reckless daring feels missing, giving the film a faint aura of depression.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
23 May 2008 · Peter Bradshaw
35*

The film feels like forcing an elderly elephant out of retirement to perform tricks, rendering it somewhat pointless despite some strong stunts and one flash of Spielberg brilliance. The familiar serial-adventure formula has lost its thrill amid overfamiliar tropes and underwhelming effects.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
20 May 2008 · Nick Schager
30*

The critic calls the film bloated and disappointingly diminutive in imagination, with Ford's Indy reduced to a sourpuss crank. It relies on nostalgia and derivative set pieces rather than invention or genuine tension.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
18 May 2008 · festival review · Kirk Honeycutt
30*

The critic finds the film a wearying onslaught of action and effects that swamps any story or character relationships. It loses the wit and romance of earlier entries and feels like work for the cast and filmmakers.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
20 May 2008 · 4 out of 5 · Mike Jennings
90*

The critic calls it an absolute triumph and a perfect tribute to the franchise, praising the action sequences performed practically and the nostalgic elements. Minor complaints include a rushed ending and one weak performance.

Read the full review →
Paste
22 May 2008 · Robert Davis
70*

The critic finds the film fun but not as good as the original, praising the action sequences' clarity and realness, Cate Blanchett's villain, and the visual style, while complaining about the convoluted plot, flat jokes, and a finale that risks cheapening the myth.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate