Most critics lean positive, six of nine, and the praise lands almost entirely on Christopher Walken. Reviewers describe his Frank White as graceful, balletic and unnerving, and several treat the performance as the thing holding an otherwise scattered film together. The New York setting draws steady approval, as do the large-scale setpieces and the flamboyance of the supporting cast; Victor Argo is picked out as the film’s quiet moral centre, and the hip-hop soundtrack earns a mention.
The spread is wide. The three negative reviews do not quarrel with the style; they quarrel with the morality, finding the film’s professed unease about violence undone by its relish for it. The Los Angeles Times and Empire both make that case, and Time Out goes further, simply finding it nasty and foul-mouthed. Even admirers concede shallow plotting, uneven characters and a lack of cohesion. The disagreement is over whether the excess is defensible.
