Most critics enjoy it, and a fair number call it the best entry in the series. The praise gathers around the animation, with the circus sequences repeatedly picked out as the film’s high point, several reviews describing them as the most accomplished thing the franchise has done. Frances McDormand’s animal-control inspector DuBois is the other recurring pleasure, with more than one critic finding her the funniest presence on screen, and a few credit Noah Baumbach’s script with a dryness the earlier films lacked. The mobster penguins get their customary mention as scene-stealers.
The reservations are about pace and substance. Several critics find it frantic to the point of exhaustion, mistaking noise for fun, and note a thin plot and little in the way of character; comparisons with Pixar are made, and not to this film’s advantage. The spread is wide, from The Guardian’s warm admiration to The Hollywood Reporter, the one clear dissenter, which finds the shouting repetitive and most of the material unfunny. Variety also objects to broad cultural stereotyping.
