Critics’ reviews

Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa (2008)

12 reviews from 12 publications. Critics’ score 56: 3 positive, 6 mixed, 3 negative.

Back to our review of Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa

56
Positive
3
Mixed
6
Negative
3

The reviews lean towards a mixed assessment of Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa, with praise clustering around the supporting characters rather than the story. The penguins repeatedly emerge as a source of laughs, while the broader visual and verbal comedy earns qualified approval. Animation is another modest strength, described as lively or skilfully handled rather than innovative. Even several critics with reservations find the sequel endearing or pleasant enough to entertain children.

The main complaints concern a thin, overcrowded story, familiar family tensions and an uncertain balance between sentiment and parody. Critics differ sharply on whether the gags compensate: Eye for Film enjoys the rush of jokes, while The Guardian finds the sequel disappointing and its plot derivative of The Lion King. The spread is substantial, though mixed notices outnumber either positive or negative ones. The recurring reservation is that appealing comic characters have too little room in a less rewarding central story.

Evening Standard
10 April 2012 · The Standard
70*

The critic finds the film tame compared with Ben Stiller’s other mainstream projects, but says it never talks down to its audience. They single out its treatment of animal appetites and inter-species romance as interesting.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
3 November 2008 · John Hazelton
64*

The page identifies this as a review, but the critic’s assessment is unavailable in the visible text. No specific praise or criticism can be verified from the accessible material.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
7 November 2008 · A.O. Scott
64*

The review’s verdict and its specific praise or criticism cannot be verified from the accessible page. The page displays only an instruction to enable JavaScript and disable ad blocking.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
6 November 2008 · ★★½/4 · Nick Schager
62

Schager finds the sequel overstuffed and uneven, but still endearing. He praises its vibrant animation and innocuously rollicking comedy.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
2 November 2008 · Kirk Honeycutt
60*

Honeycutt finds the sequel pleasant and entertaining for children, though far from pioneering and somewhat forgettable. He singles out its serviceable, skillful animation and goofy use of pop songs as modest strengths.

Read the full review →
Time Out
2 December 2008 · ★★★ · Derek Adams
60

The critic says the sequel is better than the original, but only marginally. The review singles out that slight improvement as its main distinction.

Read the full review →
Empire
16 April 2008 · Ian Nathan
55*

Nathan finds the sequel pleasing but diminished, with its script struggling to balance sentiment and parody. He praises the penguin-manned plane crash and zebra-mentality gag, but complains that overcrowding leaves too little room for the penguins and lemurs.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★ · Dave Aldridge
40

A promising opening gives way to a sequel that runs out of gas. The review praises the scene-stealing penguins but criticizes the story’s tired family-bonding and rivalry themes.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
5 December 2008 · Peter Bradshaw
25*

Bradshaw finds the sequel frankly disappointing and opportunistic. He criticizes its thin plot for shamelessly copying The Lion King.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
12 November 2008 · Tony Sullivan
75*

Sullivan had a thoroughly good time and finds the film an entertaining rush of visual and verbal gags. He especially praises the penguins, who steal every scene they appear in.

Read the full review →
Paste
7 November 2008 · Josh Jackson
70*

Jackson finds the film fun, though its story is thin and not particularly rich. He singles out the quirky secondary characters, especially the penguins, as a source of its humor and appeal.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
30 November 2008 · Alex Fletcher
30*

The critic finds the sequel merely adequate, faulting its weak story, slapdash script, and lack of laughs. They praise the surreal scenes led by King Julien and the penguins as the film’s highlights.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate