The reviews lean towards a mixed assessment of Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa, with praise clustering around the supporting characters rather than the story. The penguins repeatedly emerge as a source of laughs, while the broader visual and verbal comedy earns qualified approval. Animation is another modest strength, described as lively or skilfully handled rather than innovative. Even several critics with reservations find the sequel endearing or pleasant enough to entertain children.
The main complaints concern a thin, overcrowded story, familiar family tensions and an uncertain balance between sentiment and parody. Critics differ sharply on whether the gags compensate: Eye for Film enjoys the rush of jokes, while The Guardian finds the sequel disappointing and its plot derivative of The Lion King. The spread is substantial, though mixed notices outnumber either positive or negative ones. The recurring reservation is that appealing comic characters have too little room in a less rewarding central story.
