The reviews lean positive on Misty Green, though enthusiasm for Rosalind Eleazar is much more consistent than approval of the film around her. Critics repeatedly praise her layered, charismatic performance, finding that she makes Misty’s contradictions compelling even when the storytelling falters. Her singing draws particular notice, with several reviews identifying the musical scenes as emotionally affecting. Admirers also find sharp Hollywood satire, humour and sensitivity in Chris Rock’s direction.
The spread is wide, and the disagreements go beyond pacing. Reservations cluster around scattered plotting, too many storylines and commentary that some find familiar or muddled. Variety welcomes the drama as authentic and entertaining, while Slant Magazine argues that it lacks empathy for its central character and judges her choices rather than exploring her complexity. Even among the more favourable reviews, Eleazar often receives credit for holding together material that does not consistently serve her.
