Critics’ reviews

Misty Green (2026)

15 reviews from 15 publications. Critics’ score 64: 7 positive, 5 mixed, 3 negative.

Back to our review of Misty Green

64
Positive
7
Mixed
5
Negative
3

The reviews lean positive on Misty Green, though enthusiasm for Rosalind Eleazar is much more consistent than approval of the film around her. Critics repeatedly praise her layered, charismatic performance, finding that she makes Misty’s contradictions compelling even when the storytelling falters. Her singing draws particular notice, with several reviews identifying the musical scenes as emotionally affecting. Admirers also find sharp Hollywood satire, humour and sensitivity in Chris Rock’s direction.

The spread is wide, and the disagreements go beyond pacing. Reservations cluster around scattered plotting, too many storylines and commentary that some find familiar or muddled. Variety welcomes the drama as authentic and entertaining, while Slant Magazine argues that it lacks empathy for its central character and judges her choices rather than exploring her complexity. Even among the more favourable reviews, Eleazar often receives credit for holding together material that does not consistently serve her.

Variety
12 September 2026 · Critic's Pick · Owen Gleiberman
88*

Gleiberman calls it an explosively entertaining, authentic drama and praises Chris Rock as a major filmmaker. He singles out Rosalind Eleazar’s unguarded, charismatic performance as Misty Green.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
13 September 2026 · festival review · David Rooney
85*

Rooney finds the film smart, understated and deeply affecting, praising Chris Rock’s sensitive direction and Rosalind Eleazar’s revelatory performance. He especially singles out Eleazar’s layered portrayal and the emotional force of her musical performances.

Read the full review →
Time Out
26 September 2026 · ★★★★ · Elizabeth Weitzman
80

The review presents the film as a sharp Hollywood satire. It singles out Rosalind Eleazar as a must-see.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
7 October 2026 · Amy Nicholson
75*

Nicholson finds the film an ugly but compelling Hollywood tragicomedy and a star-making showcase for Rosalind Eleazar. She especially praises Eleazar’s performance of “Creep,” while noting that the mental-illness storyline and childhood flashbacks feel awkwardly handled.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
12 September 2026 · B- · David Ehrlich
70

Ehrlich finds the film messy and unfocused but held together by its lead performance. He especially praises Rosalind Eleazar, whose forceful work keeps the character study compelling despite its storytelling flaws.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
13 September 2026 · festival review · Tim Grierson
70*

The review presents the film as a thorny Hollywood satire, with a favorable emphasis on Rosalind Eleazar’s performance. It singles out her scorching turn as the film’s driving strength.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
festival review · Mark Asch
65*

The critic finds the film largely successful, though its plot machinations and some of its commentary fall short. Rosalind Eleazar’s restrained, sharply drawn lead performance is singled out as the film’s chief strength.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
10 October 2026 · C+ · Jesse Hassenger
63

Hassenger finds the film fascinating but frustrating, with its compelling lead nearly carrying it. He praises Rosalind Eleazar’s hypnotic performance while faulting Chris Rock’s self-centered direction and acting.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
13 September 2026 · festival review · Benjamin Lee
40*

Lee finds the film overstuffed and dramatically uneven, though Rosalind Eleazar’s performance makes it worth watching. He particularly praises her shifting, emotionally alive portrayal and the moving moment when she sings “Creep.”

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
1 October 2026 · ★½/4 · Justin Clark
38

Clark finds the film unfocused and lacking empathy, arguing it reduces a complex story about a Black woman in Hollywood to judgment of her choices. He praises Rosalind Eleazar’s performance, especially in a scene where Misty auditions for a role beneath her talent.

Read the full review →
Vulture
12 September 2026 · festival review · Alison Willmore
35*

Willmore finds the film’s critique of Hollywood clichéd and its ideas muddled, while praising Rosalind Eleazar’s outstanding performance. She singles out Eleazar’s ability to make Misty’s contradictions compelling even as the film’s portrait of her becomes spiteful.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
13 September 2026 · festival review
70*

The critic finds the film funny, entertaining and emotionally engaging, though it loses momentum and ends abruptly. Rosalind Eleazar is singled out for her commanding, heartfelt performance and as the film’s real star.

Read the full review →
Deadline
18 September 2026 · festival review · Pete Hammond
65*

The review finds the film uneven but says many of its parts work well. It singles out Rosalind Eleazar, whose performance it sees as a showcase for her emerging stardom.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
14 September 2026 · C · Chase Hutchinson
57

The critic finds the film messy and frustrating, despite its promising premise and strong performances. Rosalind Eleazar is singled out for her magnetic work, while Chris Rock’s direction and the film’s scattered storytelling draw criticism.

Read the full review →
Collider
14 September 2026 · 5/10 · Therese Lacson
50

Lacson finds the film bloated, disjointed, and dated, with too many storylines and too little character development. She praises Rosalind Eleazar’s charismatic, layered lead performance and her singing.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate