The reviews are unanimous in their approval. Nearly every critic reaches for the word essential, or something close to it, and most describe the film as devastating or unsettling. The praise clusters on the interviews: anonymous Israeli intelligence officers filmed in shadow on rooftops, speaking about targeting and killing in Gaza with a plainness critics find more chilling than any argument. Several also admire the contrast between ordinary Tel Aviv nightlife and the ruins across the border, and the restraint of the filmmaking as a whole.
The spread is narrow, and the reservations are matters of degree rather than dissent. The Guardian is uneasy about the anonymity of the sources; Little White Lies finds the film less sure of itself when it tries to be more than an extension of the filmmakers’ journalism; The Playlist thinks one visual device does not land. The Hollywood Reporter adds that the accounts of mass killing leave the viewer in despair. Nobody argues the film is dishonest, only that its methods raise questions it does not fully answer.
