The reviews lean positive on Open Your Eyes, with praise centred on its shifting perceptions, visual ambition and Eduardo Noriega’s controlled performance. Admirers find the thriller demanding but compelling, crediting Amenábar with keeping its changes of direction purposeful and unsettling. Its blend of genres and questions about appearance and reality appeal particularly to those who regard the intricate plotting as evidence of control rather than needless complication.
The spread is fairly wide, however, and the reservations concern how much that complexity delivers. Even favourable reviews find the resolution hurried or the ideas occasionally pretentious. Others describe an imaginative, stylish film whose plotting becomes confusing. Slant Magazine finds the journey hollow and preposterous despite admiring the final scene. The Guardian is more dismissive, finding the execution workmanlike and the film less rewarding than its resemblance to Buñuel and Georges Franju promises.
