Critics’ reviews

Polite Society (2023)

23 reviews from 23 publications. Critics’ score 80: 12 positive, 1 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Polite Society

80
Positive
12
Mixed
1
Negative
0

The reviews for Polite Society are almost uniformly warm and the spread is narrow: nearly every critic is positive, one is mixed, none is negative. The praise gathers around Nida Manzoor’s debut direction, the fight choreography and the chemistry between the two sisters, with Priya Kansara’s physical performance singled out again and again; several also pick out Nimra Bucha’s villain. Most critics describe the film as a genre mash-up, citing Scott Pilgrim, Edgar Wright and Jane Austen, and most enjoy the borrowing. The reservations cluster in the second half. Several find the late swerve into social thriller uneven, and a few say the finale loses momentum. The dissent is mild rather than sharp: Time Out thinks it bites off more than it can chew, The Times finds the hyperactive style a little grating, and Vulture calls it fun but unsatisfying, lacking full commitment to its genre swings. Nobody disputes the energy; the disagreement is over whether there is enough underneath it.

Empire
24 April 2023 · Ella Kemp
85*

Manzoor's debut is a delightful mash-up of British comedy and genre-bending action that celebrates sisterhood and ambition. It excels through the leads' chemistry and inventive stunt work, though the second-half thriller turn is slightly uneven.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
28 April 2023 · Monica Castillo
85*

Nida Manzoor’s riotously funny and action-packed film is a bold feature debut that defies categorization, at its core about the power of supportive sisters while critiquing cultural, generational, and gendered expectations amid high kicks and punches. It is an action comedy in the style of Edgar Wright mixed with cross-cultural commentary, sibling dynamics, and Jane Austen-style defiance, but most importantly a damn good time at the movies.

Read the full review →
Variety
21 January 2023 · Critics Pick · Peter Debruge
85*

Sixteen-year-old Ria doesn't want her older sister to get married, and she'll go to extreme lengths to keep the ceremony from happening in Nida Manzoor’s 'Scott Pilgrim'-esque Sundance sensation. Writer-director Nida Manzoor’s rowdy feature debut channels everything from Sergio Leone to “Scott Pilgrim vs. the World” in its wild and frequently outrageous route to sparing Lena the indignity of an (almost) arranged marriage.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
25 April 2023 · 4/4/4 · Fatima Sheriff
80

The critic calls the film a completely delightful debut with in-your-face comedy about crane-kicking traditional mores, highlighting South Asian Scott Pilgrim energy that is heaps of fun. Martial arts combatting marital annihilation makes for a winning combination.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
27 April 2023 · Robert Abele
80*

It’s a sisterhood of the traveling fists and feet in Nida Manzoor’s rowdy and uplifting action-comedy, a movie with a lot of fight in it literally and figuratively in advocating for centering more young women in a genre typically dominated by men. British writer-director Manzoor slams together a tangy spice mix of girl power, family drama and freaky evil into one colorfully funny good time, with music cues adding raucous punch to a badass party.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Amber Wilkinson
80

The critic finds it an effervescent and unpredictable blend of kick-ass action and comic capers from the We Are Lady Parts creator, with slick martial arts set pieces and jokes that land squarely. The unreliable first-person perspective from the sparky heroine keeps viewers guessing.

Read the full review →
Total Film
25 April 2023 · Kate Stables
80*

A wildly charming action comedy with high-energy capers and sibling bonds at its heart, boosted by inventive genre-mashing and strong performances. It stumbles only with an over-ambitious late social-thriller swerve.

Read the full review →
Time Out
★★★
60

The critic describes a lively debut that is west London's answer to Everything Everywhere All at Once, with bundles of fun and energetic filmmaking, though it bites off more than it can chew with too many styles. Manzoor is announced as an exciting filmmaker to watch.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
21 January 2023 · festival review

The critic calls it a riotous action-comedy and amusing genre mashup that radiates fizzy delight and celebrates sisterhood and individuality in a breezy good time. It is relentlessly carefree and sometimes feels insubstantial, but has such sunniness that it is hard to begrudge.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
27 April 2023

The critic praises Nida Manzoor's panache in choreographing action sequences and the film's anarchic sense of fun in a genre-jumping debut that challenges expectations about British Asian women. Some elements feel worn or diluted compared to other recent action films.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
12 March 2023 · Ross McIndoe

The critic calls it an exuberant action-comedy that understands sibling bonds and delivers confident punches and punchlines, anchored by charismatic leads and smart genre blending.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
26 April 2023 · Peter Bradshaw

The critic praises Nida Manzoor’s debut feature as a fun, energetic action comedy and pointed satire of the marriage market that delivers laughs through inventive fight scenes. It singles out the lead performance and stunt work by Priya Kansara for particular praise, comparing her to a young Jackie Chan.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
23 January 2023 · festival review · Frank Scheck

The critic finds the film raucous and audacious, praising its energetic debut from Nida Manzoor and the standout physical performance of lead Priya Kansara.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
27 April 2023 · Critic’s Pick · Amy Nicholson

This exuberant genre mash-up borrows from everything—westerns, musicals, heist capers, horror, Jane Austen and James Bond—to tell the story of two sisters in an enclave of well-to-do Muslim Londoners. It is a delight that builds writer-director Nida Manzoor into a promising new filmmaker impatient to evolve cultural representation into crowd-pleasing candy.

Read the full review →
The Times
28 April 2023 · ★★★☆☆ · Kevin Maher

The review finds the film entertaining but a little grating due to its hyperactive style and overstimulated energy. It praises the easygoing chemistry between the two lead sisters while noting the film’s self-referential, movie-mashing approach.

Read the full review →
Vulture
28 April 2023

The critic sees the film as a fun but ultimately unsatisfying mix of family dramedy and martial-arts action, praising the lead performance but noting it lacks full commitment to its genre swings.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
28 April 2023 · Andrew Robertson
90*

The critic praises the film's unbridled talent and verve, calling it a treasure with gleeful invention and specific yet widely enjoyable storytelling. They single out the confident direction and performances, especially the chemistry and inventive action sequences.

Read the full review →
/Film
23 January 2023 · 8.5/10 · Ben Pearson
85

The critic highlights the film's playful energy, humor, and charming tale of sisterly love, noting the heightened action in service of comedy and strong performances. They single out the fun, personality-driven narrative.

Read the full review →
Collider
21 January 2023 · B+ · Chase Hutchinson
83

The critic praises the film's heartfelt and humorous action-comedy blend, highlighting the strong sisterly bond and energetic fight sequences. They single out Priya Kansara's star-making performance for praise, while noting some loss of momentum in the conclusion.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
24 April 2023 · ★★★★ · Jamie Dunn
80

The critic praises the film's energetic blend of action and comedy, centered on sisterly bonds and visual invention, but notes it struggles to maintain energy in the finale.

Read the full review →
Deadline
28 April 2023 · festival review · Valerie Complex
70*

The film is a fun story exploring cultural norms and the balance between tradition and modernism in Pakistani families, critiquing them without condemnation. It features inventive storytelling, a strong cast especially the villain, and is worth seeing for laughs despite some narrative issues.

Read the full review →
Paste
28 April 2023 · 7.3 · Jacob Oller

The review lauds the energetic pastiche and how it captures teenage angst through over-the-top action and comedy. It praises the cast, especially Nimra Bucha's scene-stealing turn, but notes some repetitiveness and limitations in visual ambition.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
27 April 2023

Manzoor’s boisterous coming-of-age action-adventure is a shrewdly funny and wonderful celebration of sisterhood with an unapologetic feminist spirit. It stands out for its superbly choreographed fight sequences, agile camerawork, and fresh take on Muslim family dynamics without clichés.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate