The reviews are mixed, with praise clustering around the cast rather than a shared enthusiasm for the film. Anthony Hopkins’s Lecter remains a strong attraction for several critics, while Edward Norton and Ralph Fiennes also draw favourable notices. Supporters find an efficient, tense thriller, and some welcome its less campy tone compared with Hannibal. Even the warmer assessments tend to qualify their approval with complaints about characterisation, atmosphere or a lack of nuance.
The spread is wide, and the disagreements concern some basic strengths: Total Film praises the atmosphere, while Empire finds Brett Ratner’s visuals flat and the atmosphere lacking. Norton’s restraint strikes some critics as well judged and others as a weakness in the hero’s story. The harsher reviews see repetition and predictability where supporters find dependable thrills. Slant Magazine goes furthest, treating the familiar references and sensational plotting as evidence of a cynical reworking.
