The reviews are mixed, with admiration for Colman Domingo considerably stronger than enthusiasm for the film around him. Critics repeatedly praise his charisma, energy and warmth as Bayard Rustin, finding a layered performance even where they find the biographical drama conventional. The other recurring strength is the attention to organising the March on Washington: several reviews welcome the practical work of building coalitions and the sense of collective effort.
Reservations centre on familiar biopic habits, dutiful exposition and a shortage of dramatic tension. Some critics also find Rustin’s inner life less fully explored than his public achievements. The spread is wide: Deadline finds the film exhilarating and praises its lively handling of civil-rights debates, while Vulture finds it dull and visually static despite Domingo’s forceful performance. The central divide is over whether the energetic organising scenes and lead performance compensate for the cautious storytelling.
H
The Hollywood Reporter
1 September 2023 · festival review · Sheri Linden
85*
Linden calls the film an overdue, admiring, and nuanced tribute to Bayard Rustin. She particularly praises Colman Domingo’s vibrant performance and the film’s portrayal of the organizers’ collective effort.
Debruge finds the film compelling and sees Domingo’s performance as career-defining. He especially praises the script’s nuanced portrayal of Rustin, while noting that the march’s scale is underwhelming on screen.
Whipp finds the film an optimistic, worthwhile portrait, though its biopic conventions and restraint sometimes limit its impact. He praises Colman Domingo’s charismatic performance and the film’s nimble account of organizing the March on Washington.
The review finds that the film honors Rustin’s accomplishments but offers a weaker portrait of his inner life, particularly as a gay man. It praises Colman Domingo’s commanding performance and the energetic depiction of organizing the March on Washington.
11 September 2023 · festival review · Tim Grierson
65*
The available page identifies this as a Toronto review but does not reveal the critic’s verdict. Its standfirst singles out Rustin’s role behind the March on Washington and his sidelining because he was gay.
The URL identifies this as a review of Rustin, but the page content is inaccessible. Its verdict and any specific praise or complaint cannot be determined.
Ehrlich finds the biopic staid, but says it becomes thrilling when it embraces its theatricality. He praises its use of stagecraft to convey Rustin’s skill at building coalitions and mobilizing people.
Turner finds the film entertaining but too eager to turn grassroots organizing into uplifting spectacle. He praises Colman Domingo’s energetic, charismatic performance and the film’s attention to the everyday work of organizing.
The review finds the film an energetic but familiar biopic that lacks tension as it approaches its known conclusion. It especially praises Colman Domingo’s warm, layered performance and the humanity he brings to Rustin.
The critic finds the biopic dutiful and somewhat conventional, despite its charismatic subject. Colman Domingo’s dynamic central performance is singled out for praise.
Ebiri finds the film a dutiful, often dull biopic that works better as a history lesson than as a movie. He praises Colman Domingo’s theatrical, forceful performance while faulting the expository writing and visually static direction.
1 September 2023 · festival review · Todd McCarthy
90*
McCarthy finds the biographical drama exhilarating, fast-moving, and illuminating. He particularly praises Colman Domingo’s commanding performance and the script’s lively handling of civil-rights movement debates.
The headline signals a positive verdict, saying Colman Domingo gives the civil-rights icon his due. The accessible page does not provide further details about what the critic praises.
The review finds Rustin formulaic and too safe, but ultimately a satisfying and valuable portrait. It singles out Colman Domingo’s energetic, charismatic performance as the film’s standout strength.
The critic finds Rustin a formulaic, uninspiring biopic that fails to do justice to its subject. Colman Domingo’s committed performance is the chief strength, though the critic wishes it were in a better film.
Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate