Most critics find Sea of Love an entertaining, suspenseful thriller, with the strongest agreement centring on Al Pacino’s performance and his chemistry with Ellen Barkin. The praise goes beyond star presence: reviews pick out the vulnerability and weariness Pacino brings to the detective, and the believable sexual tension that gives the romance weight. Richard Price’s screenplay and Harold Becker’s handling of the mystery also receive credit for keeping familiar material involving.
The reservations concern plausibility, depth and how well the film holds together, with responses ranging from enthusiastic to qualified rather than hostile. Empire finds the ending unconvincing and unsatisfying, while Eye for Film welcomes the unpredictability of a late turn. The Los Angeles Times enjoys the performances but finds the entertainment superficial and formulaic. The New Yorker likewise finds plenty to enjoy, yet argues that Becker’s direction flattens material that could have been more daring.
