Most critics admire Seconds, and the praise lands in two places. James Wong Howe’s black-and-white cinematography is named again and again, described as disorienting, stark and agitated, the thing that turns a story about a bored banker into something closer to a nightmare. Rock Hudson’s performance draws nearly as much comment, with several reviews calling it revealing. The words that recur are bleak, unsettling and frightening, and most of the reviews mean them as compliments; one critic calls the film years ahead of its time.
The spread is wide. The warmest notices come from later reviews, written after the film was restored, and the one clear dissent is the earliest: Variety finds it intriguing but unsuccessful as thriller, science fiction or fable, and faults the Faustian theme as underdeveloped. Two of the nine reviews could not be read in full, so the middle ground is thinner than the numbers suggest.
