The reviews are split down the middle, and the split is a wide one. Most critics find Kore-eda’s film about a bereaved couple leasing a robot copy of their dead son handsomely made and kindly meant; the praise gathers around the performances, with Haruka Ayase singled out, and around the direction, photography and score. Even the cooler notices grant it warmth, and several call it touching in places.
The reservations are about what the film thinks. A majority find it woolly on the questions its premise raises, unwilling to say what it makes of a machine child, and so muffled rather than moving; the words sentimental and cloying recur. Some judge the quiet domestic style a poor fit for the material. The spread runs from Deadline, which calls it among Kore-eda’s purest and most dreamlike work, and The Wrap, nearly as warm, to six outright negative notices, with The Guardian finding it fails as both science fiction and grief drama.
