Most critics are unimpressed. The consensus is that Six Minutes to Midnight has an intriguing historical premise and spends it on a conventional spy thriller, with several reviewers saying the real history of the school is more fascinating than anything the film does with it. Where there is praise it goes to Judi Dench, whose performance is picked out for giving her character an emotional coherence the rest of the cast lacks, and in passing to the Welsh scenery and Marc Streitenfeld’s score.
The reservations cluster on the plotting, which the reviews call clichéd, creaky and meandering, with stock characters and perfunctory dialogue. Eddie Izzard divides them: Time Out finds the performance stiff and The Guardian calls the casting a mistake, while Eye for Film, the one clearly positive review, praises Izzard for carrying the character’s many sides. The spread is wide, from Vulture, which finds the film underwritten and television-like, to HeyUGuys, which thinks the second half rescues a slow first.
