Most critics find Spa Weekend a weak ensemble comedy whose cast deserves better material. The praise centres on Leslie Mann, Isla Fisher, Michelle Buteau and Anna Faris, with Fisher’s energy and Buteau’s comic delivery drawing particular approval. Even several negative reviews find something to enjoy in the performances. The prevailing complaint is that predictable jokes, thin characters and repetitive slapstick leave the film’s satire of wellness culture short of bite.
The disagreement concerns how much the performers can rescue. IndieWire finds a messy but spirited comedy sustained by the four leads’ chemistry, while Time Out enjoys the friendship and humour despite the formula, particularly Buteau’s jokes. These are exceptions in a largely negative set of reviews. Elsewhere, reservations range from disappointment at tame antics and shallow emotion to stronger objections about condescending treatment of the women. For most critics, the occasional laugh does not compensate for the weak script.
