Critics’ reviews

Star Trek (2009)

16 reviews from 16 publications. Critics’ score 84: 9 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Star Trek

84
Positive
9
Mixed
0
Negative
0

Most critics welcome Star Trek as an energetic revival that respects familiar characters while making their early adventures accessible to newcomers. Praise centres on Abrams’s pace, humour and casting, with Chris Pine’s Kirk and Zachary Quinto’s Spock drawing particular attention for their rivalry and comic timing. The reviews also favour the effects and refreshed design. Many find that the action leaves enough space for friendships and character development to matter.

The differences are chiefly in the degree of enthusiasm, though some reservations are specific. Slant Magazine finds the opening weak, the film uneven and the villain and action short on originality, while still valuing the supporting cast and humour. Total Film, by contrast, singles out the opening as a strength. The Los Angeles Times notes an over-caffeinated quality and occasional missteps, but shares the broader view that Abrams successfully brings old and new together.

Screen Daily
22 April 2009
85*

Abrams is praised for injecting enormous energy into the long-running franchise and creating an immensely satisfying prequel with invigorating humour and strong casting. The review highlights the director’s understanding of modern audiences and the film’s potential as a summer hit.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
7 May 2009 · 4/4/4 · Jonathan Crocker
80

Abrams’s reboot is hailed as the most purely enjoyable blockbuster of the summer for its speed, style and exhilarating action sequences. The critic singles out the dynamic rivalry between Pine’s cocky Kirk and Quinto’s ice-cool Spock for particular praise.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
· Kim Newman
80*

The review praises Abrams’s bold reimagining of the early days of the Star Trek crew. It highlights the love and respect with which the reboot has been mounted despite being a radical rethink.

Read the full review →
Time Out
5 May 2009 · ★★★★ · Tom Huddleston
80

Abrams is commended for updating the franchise with enthusiasm and fun without dark allegory or excessive violence. The critic praises the witty design updates, strong cast and clever script that works for both fans and newcomers.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
· Andrew Collins
75*

The reboot is described as a successful revival of the classic formula with big-budget effects and in-jokes that appeal to new and old audiences alike. The young cast and Abrams’s direction are credited with breathing fresh life into the series.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
8 May 2009 · Kenneth Turan

The critic finds the film successful overall in bridging old and new, with a satisfying young-years setup and strong action sequences, though it has over-caffeinated aspects and occasional missteps; Abrams’ playful instinct for popular entertainment ultimately saves it.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
6 May 2009 · Bill Weber

The critic views the film as a qualified success that recovers from a weak opening but remains goofily uneven, crediting it with restoring the scale of the Trek universe through fan-service references and a strong supporting cast while noting the villain and action sequences lack originality. The presence of Leonard Nimoy as older Spock and comedic riffs by the new cast are singled out as highlights amid the revisionist plot.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
8 May 2009 · Peter Bradshaw

The critic praises the film's focus on the bromance between Kirk and Spock as the greatest of its kind. He singles out the inspired, lovable performances by Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto for their power, passion and comic timing.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
20 April 2009 · Ray Bennett

The critic praises J.J. Abrams for giving the over-the-hill Star Trek franchise a full refit with warp-speed pacing, spectacular action sequences, and an expert cast that makes the familiar characters instantly recognizable. The film is highlighted as so much fun that it will appeal to both saga fans and general audiences seeking a sensational ride, with special effects and production values singled out for praise.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
8 May 2009 · Critic’s Pick · Manohla Dargis

The critic praises the film as a bright, shiny blast and pleasurable rethink of the franchise, an origin story directed with a sure touch and perfect tone by J.J. Abrams that turns back the narrative clock to the characters’ early days.

Read the full review →
Total Film
8 April 2009

The film is an exhilarating, breathless and lavishly mounted adventure that delivers the first genuine blockbuster of the year. It is singled out for its powerful opening and the way it brings the Enterprise crew together.

Read the full review →
Variety
22 April 2009 · Todd McCarthy

The critic calls it a smart and breathless space adventure that transports fans to sci-fi nirvana, faithful to the spirit of the original while exciting on its own terms with youthful energy, strong casting, and top-notch effects and score.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
20 April 2009 · ★★★★★ · Mark Pickavance
100

The critic is ecstatic that the film delivers a fresh yet familiar Star Trek experience that is highly entertaining, with exceptional visuals, action, and strong characterizations, especially from the lead actors. He singles out the dynamic action sequences and the way the film balances spectacle with character development for praise.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
20 April 2009 · Ben Rawson-Jones
90*

The critic praises the film as a gripping reboot that blends breathtaking visuals with a character-driven script, delivering an enjoyable blockbuster focused on Kirk's coming-of-age story and the formation of key friendships. He singles out the strong performances and Abrams' direction for balancing action and character moments.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
5 May 2009 · Michael Adams
90*

The critic finds the film one of the most rollicking sci-fi adventures in a long time—smart, funny and emotionally satisfying. He singles out Abrams' genuine curiosity balanced with reverence and humor in handling the familiar material.

Read the full review →
Paste
8 May 2009 · Paste Staff
80*

The critic finds the film an exciting, dramatic, and intelligent summer blockbuster that is more than mere spectacle. They single out the nimble story by screenwriters Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman for linking to predecessors with minimal plot holes and the blazing pace and smart dialogue.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate