Stardust (2007)

Pendreigh gives the adaptation a positive review, comparing its appeal to classic fantasy adventures. He praises its imagination, scale, humour and cross-generational appeal.

Robinson finds the film an overextended but enjoyable fantasy that settles for expansive joy rather than dramatic tautness. She particularly praises Robert De Niro’s playful performance and the terrific effects.

Ebert regards the film as an entertaining fantasy adventure. He praises its charm and playful storytelling.

Jolin finds Stardust patchy but great fun, with a sweet, silly fairy-tale romance. He praises its black humour, especially the cartoon-comical deaths of the princes.

The critic finds the fantasy adventure diverting and pleasurable, though its humor sometimes weakens its enchantment. Michelle Pfeiffer’s resourceful, genuinely frightening performance is singled out for praise, while the comedy is criticized for falling flat.

Goodridge describes the film as entertaining, ribald and clever, but hints that it may fall short. He singles out its ambitious high-concept adventure premise as a strength.

Mackie finds the film colourful and lively, though it does not entirely hang together. He especially praises Michelle Pfeiffer’s performance and the cast’s comic leeway.

The review finds the film has plenty of seductive qualities. It praises the adaptation’s roistering glee.

The review calls the film uneven but entertaining, with its uncertain tone and overstuffed storytelling holding it back. It praises Michelle Pfeiffer’s performance as the witch Lamia as a particular reason to watch.

Gonzalez finds the adaptation competent but uninspired, weighed down by spectacle and plot holes. He praises Michelle Pfeiffer’s memorable performance and the climax’s inventive, morbid swordfight.

The critic calls the film brilliant, funny, and spectacular, and says it suits the whole family. He particularly praises Robert De Niro’s performance and the film’s supporting cast.

Carty finds the fantasy charming and inventive, though uneven and short of its full potential. He praises the cast, especially Claire Danes and the wealth of seasoned supporting performers.