The consensus on Stuart Little is mixed, with praise clustering around the effects rather than the storytelling. Critics repeatedly admire how convincingly the computer-generated mouse interacts with the live-action cast, including several who find the film disappointing. The animal characters’ humour and voice work also earn approval, with the cats frequently singled out. Warmer reviews find enough charm and gentle fun to make it enjoyable family entertainment.
The divide is over how much sweetness the story can sustain. Several critics find it overly sentimental, while others point to an uninspired narrative and human characters who seem awkward or dull beside the animals. Responses range widely: the Evening Standard warmly endorses the classic storytelling, whereas the Los Angeles Times finds the film dull and largely uninvolving. Comparisons with the book bring further reservations about the loss of its mystery and magic, even among critics who enjoy the adaptation.
