Most critics respond warmly to The Dark Crystal, with praise clustering around its puppetry, creature designs and richly detailed fantasy setting. The reviews repeatedly find that the handmade characters have energy and personality, making the adventure engaging beyond its technical achievement. Several also value the humour, heartfelt wonder and moral concerns, particularly the story’s interest in healing and balance.
The reservations centre on storytelling rather than craftsmanship, though the available verdicts range from qualified approval to strong enthusiasm rather than outright rejection. The AV Club finds the pacing uneven and the video effects dated, while maintaining that the puppetry remains convincing. Den of Geek offers the clearest reservation about the writing, arguing that the visual imagination exceeds the storytelling. Collider is more enthusiastic about the story itself, finding its message nuanced and its concerns still relevant.
