
The reviews lean mildly positive, though most critics land in the middle: a competent, well-acted espionage thriller rather than a distinguished one. The praise clusters on the cast. Jessica Chastain is the name that recurs most often, usually alongside Helen Mirren, and several critics single out Jesper Christensen’s calm, chilling turn as the Nazi surgeon, with the tense safe-house scenes between him and Chastain cited as the film’s strongest stretch. The flashback material in Berlin is admired for its grit and suspense.
The reservations cluster just as tightly, on the final act. Critic after critic calls the ending implausible, contrived or preposterous, and several feel the love triangle sits uneasily beside the crimes the story is built around; a few find the 1990s sections slacker than the flashbacks. The spread is narrow, with only one outright dismissal: The Guardian finds it dramatically unconvincing and morally unsatisfying, while the Los Angeles Times is the lone unreserved admirer.
L
Los Angeles Times
31 August 2011 · Betsy Sharkey
90*
Sharkey finds the film a superbly crafted, brainy espionage thriller with strong momentum. She especially praises Jesper Christensen’s chilling, nuanced performance as the Nazi surgeon.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
27 September 2011 · ★★★★ · Anna Smith
80
The review is positive, suggesting the thriller sells itself through its cast. It singles out Helen Mirren, Ciarán Hinds and Tom Wilkinson as the main draw.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
15 September 2011 · ★★★★ · Neil Smith
80
Smith finds the film a gripping thriller, though its final act is preposterous and its revenge premise feels superficial beside Munich. He singles out Jessica Chastain’s performance as especially memorable.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
30 August 2011 · B · Nathan Rabin
77
Rabin finds the film’s exploration of guilt and identity compelling but says its love triangle feels trivial beside the Nazi crimes at its center. He singles out the tense encounters between Chastain and Christensen for praise.
Read the full review →E
Empire
30 April 2008 · William Thomas
65*
Thomas finds the thriller smart, tense and worthwhile despite a disappointing finale. He singles out Jessica Chastain and Helen Mirren’s performances as its highlight.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
10 April 2012 · The Standard
65*
The critic finds the thriller engaging despite an occasionally loose plot and an implausible final section. Helen Mirren and Jessica Chastain are singled out for their strong performances.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
14 October 2010 · Kirk Honeycutt
65*
Honeycutt finds the thriller effective overall, though its timeline creates a jarring problem for the ending. He praises the vivid characters and suspenseful production, especially the cinematography, sets, and score.
Read the full review →The page could not be accessed, so its verdict is unavailable. No praise or criticism can be reliably identified.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
4 September 2010 · festival review · John Hazelton
64*
The page identifies this as a review, but the critic’s verdict is hidden behind the paywall. The accessible metadata provides no specific praise or criticism.
Read the full review →The review’s verdict could not be determined because the article was inaccessible. No praise or complaint from the critic was available to identify.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★ · Dave Aldridge
60
The critic calls it decent but unspectacular, with the cast lifting it above the ordinary. They single out the calibre of the performances, including Helen Mirren, Sam Worthington, Tom Wilkinson and Jessica Chastain.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
· Kate Stables
60*
Kate Stables finds it a sturdy psychological suspense thriller, though its final act strains credibility. She praises its intriguing focus on the dilemmas of a female lead agent.
Read the full review →The review finds the thriller uneven, with its implausible plot weighed down by gloomy reflection. It praises Jesper Christensen for a calm, clever performance that dominates the film.
Read the full review →V
Vulture
2 September 2011 · David Edelstein
55*
Edelstein finds the thriller gripping despite its increasingly absurd turns. He praises the carefully built suspense, especially the weight carried by the characters’ faces.
Read the full review →V
Variety
4 September 2010 · Jordan Mintzer
50*
Mintzer finds the thriller polished and suspenseful but weighed down by conventional plotting and an overdone love triangle. He praises the flashbacks’ gritty details and the film’s skillful handling of its multiple locations and time periods.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
1 October 2011 · Philip French
30*
French finds the thriller dramatically unconvincing and morally unsatisfactory. He praises the tense Berlin operation and Jesper Christensen’s chilling Nazi portrayal.
Read the full review →D
Digital Spy
8 September 2011 · Simon Reynolds
75*
The review finds the film smart, involving entertainment, despite some jarring visual matches between the younger and older cast. It especially praises the performances of Helen Mirren and Jessica Chastain.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
8 September 2011 · 3 out of 5 · Ryan Lambie
72*
Lambie finds the film a mildly diverting thriller, but says its 1990s sections make the story stumble. He praises Jesper Christensen’s hypnotic performance as the Nazi war criminal.
Read the full review →H
HeyUGuys
8 August 2011 · ★★★½ · Anthony Charles
70
The critic finds it an entertaining, solid political thriller, though it loses momentum and its reveals can be predictable. Helen Mirren’s strong performance is singled out as a major asset.
Read the full review →C
Collider
31 August 2011 · C- · Matt Goldberg
50
Goldberg finds the film uneven, criticizing its unclear characterization and its shift toward conventional spy-thriller plotting. He praises the tense safe-house sequence, where the operatives confront their fears and the mission’s moral complications.
Read the full review →P
Paste
1 September 2011 · David Roark
50*
Roark finds the film suspenseful and well-acted, but says its contrived ending undermines its moral argument. He particularly praises Jessica Chastain’s performance and the polished direction, which make the thriller’s characters matter.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate