Critics’ reviews

The Girl with All the Gifts (2016)

18 reviews from 18 publications. Critics’ score 71: 13 positive, 2 mixed, 3 negative.

Back to our review of The Girl with All the Gifts

71
Positive
13
Mixed
2
Negative
3

Most critics come away won over, and the praise lands in the same place: Sennia Nanua as Melanie. Review after review calls her performance the film’s chief asset, a child who is recognisably a child and unnerving at the same time. Beyond her, the reviews credit the film with putting fresh thought into a tired genre, with a moral seriousness about its warring characters, and with a melancholy atmosphere that several find moving. Glenn Close draws repeated mention for scene-stealing work, and the score and production design are singled out by The Guardian.

The spread is wide. Even admirers note predictable beats, a slack middle stretch and a repetitive soundtrack. The firm dissent comes from the festival trade reviews: The Hollywood Reporter finds it dreary and dramatically inert, Variety calls it overlong and tired, though Variety still likes Nanua. The Los Angeles Times finds it competent but routine, with direction and performances that rarely stand out.

Little White Lies
21 September 2016 · 4/5/4 · Anton Bitel
100

Bitel praises the film as a morally complex, character-focused take on familiar zombie-horror territory. He singles out Sennia Nanua’s performance and the film’s sympathetic handling of its characters’ conflicting positions.

Read the full review →
Time Out
18 September 2016 · ★★★★★ · Joshua Rothkopf
100

The critic calls it a radical, brilliant zombie film that refreshes a tired genre. They single out its inventive take on the undead as a major strength.

Read the full review →
Empire
19 September 2016 · Helen O'Hara
85*

O'Hara calls it the best zombie-ish apocalypse in years, praising its tense atmosphere and moral complexity. She singles out Sennia Nanua as a major discovery, especially for balancing Melanie's childlike curiosity with her cunning.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
3 October 2016 · Charlotte O'Sullivan
85*

O'Sullivan finds the film a moving, hopeful end-of-the-world story despite a few missteps. She particularly praises its melancholy atmosphere and the final twists that return focus to Melanie and her teacher.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
26 September 2016 · Nikki Baughan
85*

Baughan finds the film a potent, intelligent horror story whose emotional force grows from Melanie’s journey. She particularly praises Sennia Nanua’s nuanced performance and the character’s blend of innocence, terror and purpose.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Alan Jones
80

The critic calls it a heartfelt, powerful cautionary tale. They praise the adaptation’s visual resonance and Sennia Nanua’s performance.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
25 September 2016 · ★★★★ · Mark Kermode
80

Kermode praises the film as a provocative, imaginative work that reinvents familiar horror tropes. He especially singles out Sennia Nanua’s nuanced performance and the film’s distinctive, uncanny score and production design.

Read the full review →
Total Film
12 September 2016 · ★★★★ · Kevin Harley
80

The critic finds the film tender, terrifying, ingenious, and intense, despite some plot rambling and slackened tension. Sennia Nanua’s performance stands out, balancing recognisable childhood behaviour with unsettling intelligence.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
3 August 2016 · B · Eric Kohn
77

Kohn finds the film a thrilling, elegant zombie story that refreshes familiar genre conventions, despite relying on some predictable beats. He praises Sennia Nanua’s startling performance and the film’s eerie imagery, especially in its Bosch-like finale.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
3 August 2016 · festival review · Charles Gant
65*

The accessible page confirms a Locarno review of the 2016 film, but does not reveal the critic’s verdict. The paywall also hides any discussion of what the critic praises or criticizes.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
23 February 2017
65*

The accessible page does not reveal the critic’s verdict or specific praise or complaint. The URL identifies this as a review, but the article text is unavailable.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
23 February 2017 · Robert Abele
40*

Abele finds the film professionally engrossing but ultimately routine and unremarkable. He praises its smart ideas about the post-outbreak world, while noting that its direction and performances rarely stand out.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
3 August 2016 · festival review · Boyd van Hoeij
20*

The critic finds the film dreary and dramatically ineffective, with little chance of lasting impact. Glenn Close’s gleefully over-the-top performance is the one thing singled out for praise.

Read the full review →
Variety
3 August 2016 · festival review · Jay Weissberg
20*

Weissberg finds the film an overlong, tired entry in the zombie genre. He praises newcomer Sennia Nanua’s charm but criticizes the direction, script, and repetitive music.

Read the full review →
Collider
24 February 2017 · B+ · Haleigh Foutch
83

Foutch finds the film a fresh, thoughtful revival of the zombie genre. She especially praises Sennia Nanua’s captivating and unsettling performance as Melanie.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
22 September 2016 · ★★★★ · Ryan Lambie
80

The critic finds it an intelligent zombie film whose strong acting and writing overcome some budgetary and soundtrack flaws. He particularly praises Glenn Close’s performance and the hypnotic story scene that showcases her skill.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
festival review · Melanie
75*

The critic recommends the film as a distinctive zombie thriller, despite a few predictable moments. Sennia Nanua’s performance and the development of Melanie are singled out for praise.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
25 February 2017
75*

The critic finds the film a fresh, empathetic addition to an overworked zombie genre. They praise the moving relationship between Gemma Arterton and Sennia Nanua, with Glenn Close also singled out for scene-stealing work.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate