Critics’ reviews

The Guest (2014)

23 reviews from 23 publications. Critics’ score 73: 18 positive, 3 mixed, 2 negative.

Back to our review of The Guest

73
Positive
18
Mixed
3
Negative
2

Most critics enjoy The Guest, and they agree on why. Nearly every review singles out Dan Stevens as the mysterious soldier: charming, controlled and quietly wrong, a long way from his respectable image, and the thing that holds the film’s mix of tones together. The other recurring pleasure is the debt to 1980s genre cinema, John Carpenter in particular, and the synth score that goes with it. Dark comedy, pulpy violence and knowing pastiche are the words that keep coming up.

The reservations cluster around the final act. Several otherwise warm reviews find the climax runs too long, loses its logic or lands as an afterthought. The spread is narrow, with only a handful of dissenters: Little White Lies calls it a hollow mash-up with thin characters, Vulture finds the twists predictable and poorly handled, and The Hollywood Reporter says the tension falters. Maika Monroe gets less attention than she might, though Digital Spy makes her the film’s emotional centre.

Los Angeles Times
15 September 2014 · Robert Abele
90*

Abele finds the thriller a tough, fun homage to 1980s genre cinema, with cheeky craft and potent thrills. He especially praises Dan Stevens’ mesmerizing, psychotically charming performance as the mysterious soldier.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
16 September 2014 · B+ · A.A. Dowd
83

Dowd finds the film wickedly entertaining, praising its blend of ruthless action, dark comedy, and genre pastiche. Dan Stevens is singled out for making David an indelible villain who holds the mix of tones together.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Damon Wise
80

The critic regards the film as a tense throwback thriller. He singles out its pulpy 1980s influences and Dan Stevens’s departure from his respectable image.

Read the full review →
Time Out
1 September 2014 · ★★★★ · Guy Lodge
80

The visible description suggests a qualified view of the film’s marketing hook. It singles out Dan Stevens’s casting as the angle under discussion.

Read the full review →
Total Film
1 September 2014 · ★★★★ · Matt Glasby
80

Glasby finds the film an entertaining, over-the-top action-horror, though its third act lasts too long. He particularly praises the performances, sharp dialogue, humor, and pulsing synth score.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
16 September 2014 · B · Cory Everett
77

The critic calls the film a fast-paced, entertaining genre throwback, despite a weaker, illogical third act. They praise Dan Stevens’s magnetic performance and the film’s Carpenter-inspired synth score.

Read the full review →
Empire
12 August 2014 · David Hughes
75*

Hughes finds the film an unusually clever, entertaining thriller that rewards viewers who tune into its oddball tone. He particularly praises Dan Stevens’ mesmerising performance and the film’s well-judged music score.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
10 September 2014 · Charlotte O'Sullivan
75*

O'Sullivan finds the film compelling and playfully unsettling, though its twists keep the viewer unsure whose side to take. She singles out Dan Stevens's intelligence and charisma as crucial to its success.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
13 September 2014 · ★★★/4 · Ed Gonzalez
75

Gonzalez finds the film a stylish, entertaining piece of pulp, though it lacks depth and its finale feels like an afterthought. He praises Wingard’s audiovisual flair, especially the way the soundtrack is synchronized with the characters’ shifting emotions.

Read the full review →
Variety
20 January 2014 · festival review · Dennis Harvey
75*

Harvey calls the film a giddily violent, high-grade treat for genre fans, though its climax and final twist disappoint. He especially praises Dan Stevens’s performance and the film’s cheesy synth-driven grindhouse style.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
4 September 2014 · Anna Smith
70*

Smith finds the film muddled at times but consistently entertaining. She praises its gleeful, knowing throwback to 1980s horror-thrillers.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
64*

The URL identifies a review of the specified film, but the page content is unavailable. The browser verification screen provides no critic verdict or praise to summarize.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
18 January 2014 · festival review · Justin Lowe
45*

Lowe finds the thriller mixed, with tension that falters and plot strands that feel underdeveloped. He praises Wingard’s controlled visual direction and the filmmakers’ ironic humor.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
4 September 2014 · 4/2/2 · David Jenkins
40

Jenkins finds the film an underwhelming, hollow genre mash-up that squanders its potential. He criticizes its thin characters and lack of meaningful metaphor, despite the intriguing setup.

Read the full review →
Vulture
17 September 2014 · Bilge Ebiri
40*

Ebiri finds the film entertaining in stretches but ultimately undermined by predictable plotting and poorly executed twists. He praises Dan Stevens’s compellingly insincere performance and the film’s atmospheric aesthetic, especially its Halloween-tunnel setpiece and synth-heavy soundtrack.

Read the full review →
Consequence
17 September 2014 · Randall Colburn
90*

Colburn gives the film a strongly positive verdict, calling it a genre masterpiece. He particularly praises Dan Stevens’s disciplined, nuanced performance and the film’s deft balance of nostalgic influences with a modern feel.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
5 September 2014 · Ben Rawson-Jones
90*

The critic calls the film a hugely enjoyable, gripping thriller with strong cult-classic potential. Maika Monroe is singled out for bringing emotional depth and empathy to the story.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
24 August 2014 · festival review · Owen Van Spall
90*

The critic finds the film slick, tense, funny and technically sharp, and says Frightfest chose its launch film well. He particularly praises Dan Stevens’s charismatic performance and the inventive, tightly staged action sequences.

Read the full review →
Collider
19 January 2014 · B+ · Matt Goldberg
83

Goldberg finds the film an entertaining, gleefully dark Carpenter-style thriller, though its later shift in tone becomes too dark and silly. He singles out Dan Stevens’s charismatic, carefully balanced performance as the film’s greatest strength.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
17 September 2014 · ★★★★ · Don Kaye
80

The critic calls the film fun, entertaining, smart, and Wingard and Barrett’s most accomplished effort yet. He especially praises Dan Stevens’s performance and the well-crafted relationships that keep the familiar thriller gripping.

Read the full review →
/Film
18 September 2014 · 8 out of 10 · Germain Lussier
79*

The critic finds the film fresh, fun, and highly entertaining despite a brief loss of playful momentum. They praise its tight script and editing, along with Steve Moore’s catchy synthesizer score.

Read the full review →
NME
75*

The review is enthusiastic, though it finds the film’s knowing archness occasionally too forced. It especially praises Dan Stevens’s performance and the film’s playful, inventive use of horror conventions.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
4 September 2014 · ★★★ · Chris Fyvie
60

Fyvie calls it a slight but highly entertaining ride. He praises Dan Stevens’s wry performance and the film’s cheeky wit.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate