The reviews are divided, with mixed and negative responses outnumbering positive ones. Praise centres on the storm effects, the scale of the waves and the tension of the rescue sequences; even some detractors acknowledge the spectacle’s force. The more enthusiastic critics find an exciting, old-fashioned blockbuster, while a recurring reservation across favourable and unfavourable reviews is that the characters lack the depth to make the danger emotionally compelling.
The spread is wide, and the disagreement extends to both the build-up and the effects. The Guardian welcomes the time spent developing the story before the storm, whereas the Evening Standard finds the setup sluggish and the character drama weak. The AV Club offers a different objection, finding the details of fishing and the characters’ lives more interesting than the storm spectacle. Elsewhere, complaints cluster around formula, sentimentality and effects that overwhelm the actors.
