Critics’ reviews

The Royal Hotel (2023)

25 reviews from 25 publications. Critics’ score 76: 14 positive, 3 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of The Royal Hotel

76
Positive
14
Mixed
3
Negative
0

Most critics like The Royal Hotel, and the spread is narrow: no outright negative reviews, and the doubters are lukewarm rather than hostile. The praise clusters around two things. The first is Julia Garner, whose watchful, tightly controlled performance is singled out in almost every review, with Jessica Henwick and Hugo Weaving getting steady if quieter credit. The second is Kitty Green’s handling of dread, the way small indignities in a remote outback pub accumulate until violence feels a breath away, which several critics call gripping and a few call close to unbearable. The reservations cluster around the last act and the two women themselves. The Hollywood Reporter finds the climax mechanical rather than cathartic, Vulture thinks the central friendship goes underexplored, and Sight and Sound judges it a less subtle film than Green’s earlier The Assistant. Little White Lies is the coolest voice, finding it harrowing but not as deeply unsettling as hoped.

Evening Standard
6 November 2023 · Hanna Flint
85*

The critic hails the film as a searing comment on contemporary gender politics that simmers with oppressive testosterone before boiling over into cathartic female rage. It is skilfully told and exquisitely performed, with Julia Garner's hyper-vigilant portrayal singled out amid the nervy tension and explosive finale.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
4 November 2023
85*

The critic calls the film brilliant and nerve-shredding, praising Kitty Green's follow-up to The Assistant for its tense depiction of a woman's perspective in a threatening male-dominated setting. They highlight Julia Garner's superb performance and the film's smart, understated psychological thriller elements amid the outback bar atmosphere.

Read the full review →
Variety
16 September 2023 · Critics Pick · Amy Nicholson
85*

The critic calls it an ulcer-inducing thriller that uses genre conventions to sharpen awareness of toxic dynamics everywhere, based on a real documentary. She praises the director's control in making every scene gripping and pointed without feeling hectoring, highlighting the leads' performances.

Read the full review →
Empire
3 November 2023 · Sophie Butcher
80*

The critic calls it a slight but mightily effective adrenaline rush of a movie that delivers powerful performances and precise direction from Kitty Green while building stomach-churning dread. The unsettling atmosphere of the remote mining pub and the controlled, convincing lead turn by Julia Garner are highlighted as the tension escalates.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
6 October 2023 · Jessica Kiang
80*

The critic describes the film as a queasily gripping thriller exposing familiar dread through a taxonomy of male aggression in an isolated outback bar. She singles out its precise recreation of situations that make viewers judge the women's choices while highlighting varied toxic behaviors.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
★★★★
80

The review describes the film as a chilling, gripping slow-burn thriller about two backpackers in a menacing outback pub, crediting strong performances especially from Hugo Weaving and the young Australian cast. It notes the film's effective build of unease drawn from real-life inspirations.

Read the full review →
Time Out
31 October 2023 · ★★★★
80

Two backpackers face a tense standoff with boozy blokes in an outback pub thriller that heightens the risk through its Australian setting. The film traces a line from classic outback shockers while Garner anchors the off-kilter tone effectively.

Read the full review →
The Independent
4 October 2023 · ★★★/4 · Mark Kennedy
75

The critic finds the film a subtle, captivating psychological thriller about two American backpackers facing toxic masculinity in a remote Australian pub, but advises not to linger too long in its discomforting atmosphere. It builds tension through accumulating indignities and a pessimistic view of gender relations, with strong performances from the leads.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
· Amber Wilkinson
70*

American backpackers take bar jobs in the outback serving a male-dominated clientele that dishes out toxic masculinity. Director Kitty Green stokes an atmosphere where microaggressions add up and violence always feels imminent, though the second half strains credibility.

Read the full review →
Vulture
6 October 2023
70*

The thriller builds secondhand-hangover tension through the women's constant recalibration in male spaces, proving effective if messier and less devastating than Green's prior work, though the central friendship feels underexplored.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
2 November 2023 · 4/3/3 · Mark Asch
60

Green delivers more cinema of ominous discomfort in an out-of-the-way Australian boozer with low-boiling violence. It is harrowing but does not burrow under the skin as deeply as hoped, with a schematic contrast between the protagonists and a cathartic third-act escalation.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
2 September 2023 · David Ehrlich

Green re-teams with Garner for a pulpier, more explosive tale of the male gaze and workplace abuse in the outback, where the two backpackers navigate constant threat from drunken miners.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
8 September 2023 · festival review

Kitty Green delivers a further devastating drama on toxic masculinity as two female friends discover how inhospitable the Australian Outback can be. It is an unsettling psychological thriller in which the possibility of violence looms heavily, with strong work from the lead actresses.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
11 October 2023

The film builds a queasy, swampy atmosphere around two American backpackers working in a remote Australian pub as the threat of violence grows. It examines what women are willing to put up with for politeness, livelihood and safety in a less subtle follow-up to The Assistant.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
26 September 2023 · Gregory Nussen

Green's dread-inducing vision keeps viewers on a knife's edge amid constant threat of violence in the outback bar, using sonic and horror tropes to convey the deadening effect of sexual abuse with diamond-hard precision.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
3 September 2023 · festival review · Sheri Linden

The film delivers a pummeling experience of dread overload in a remote outback pub, with strong performances from Garner and Henwick as friends facing escalating menace, but the climax feels mechanical rather than cathartic.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
5 October 2023 · NYT Critic’s Pick · Jeannette Catsoulis

The critic finds the film a coolly calibrated thriller in which two young women bartend in a remote Australian pub amid menacing male patrons. She praises the pervasive mood of clammy menace created through language and setting, along with strong performances from the leads.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
4 September 2023 · festival review
85*

The critic calls it a riveting thriller in which Green flexes her genre muscles, with strong performances from Julia Garner and Jessica Henwick. The review highlights the unnerving atmosphere, male entitlement, and an explosive ending fueled by female rage.

Read the full review →
Deadline
11 September 2023 · festival review · Pete Hammond
80*

The critic praises the shift in style from Green’s previous film and lauds the performances by Garner, Henwick, and Weaving along with the pitch-perfect atmosphere. It notes the film’s effective handling of escalating drama and tension around male behavior without painting all men as monsters.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
17 October 2023 · ★★★★ · Lisa Giles-Keddie
80

The film is a tense drama exploring toxic masculinity and isolation as two backpackers take a bar job in a remote outback pub. Garner excels as the watchful Hanna navigating escalating threats and survival choices.

Read the full review →
/Film
19 September 2023 · 7.5/10 · Barry Levitt
75

Kitty Green delivers a nerve-shredding thriller about two women facing escalating dangers while working in an isolated outback bar. The film effectively amps up themes of entitlement and toxicity with strong performances, especially from Weaving.

Read the full review →
Collider
18 September 2023 · C+ · Isabella Soares
63

Julia Garner delivers an immersive performance capturing a guarded woman, while Jessica Henwick's character lacks depth. The set design and cinematography create a chilling atmosphere, and the film highlights challenges women face in a male-dominated world, but it falls short on developing characters and motivations, making the ending bittersweet.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
11 October 2023 · Amber Wilkinson
60*

Green returns to themes of toxic masculinity in a tense outback setting where microaggressions keep characters on edge. The mood is gripping but the women's relationship strains believability and some elements feel overly familiar.

Read the full review →
Paste
5 October 2023 · 8.5 · Andy Crump

Kitty Green's film explores misogyny and cultural clashes in an Australian outback pub through two backpackers' experiences, highlighting normalized harassment but offering a somewhat upbeat resolution compared to her previous work.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
7 September 2023 · C+/B- · Gregory Ellwood

Garner impresses in a simmering thriller about misogyny and culture clash in a remote Australian pub. The film builds tension effectively but leaves too much ambiguous and falters in its final act.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate