The reviews lean towards qualified enjoyment, with praise clustering around Vince Vaughn and Owen Wilson rather than the writing. Their chemistry and contrasting comic styles make the bawdy humour work for several critics, including some who find the film disappointing. Rachel McAdams also earns praise for giving the romance a convincing character, while the warmer notices find enough charm to carry the comedy beyond its male-bonding antics.
The spread is wide, however, and the script and pacing draw repeated complaints. Reservations range from implausibility and patchy jokes to a prolonged, sentimental finale. Even favourable reviews acknowledge the formula. The AV Club finds that the early energy gives way to broad, clumsy, slow comedy despite the cast’s charisma. At the enthusiastic end, Eye for Film finds it exceptionally funny, singling out Isla Fisher and the eccentric Cleary family. The disagreement is largely over how much the performers can compensate for the material.
