Critics’ reviews

When Evil Lurks (2023)

12 reviews from 12 publications. Critics’ score 72: 9 positive, 3 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of When Evil Lurks

72
Positive
9
Mixed
3
Negative
0

Most critics like When Evil Lurks: nine of the twelve reviews are positive and none is negative. The praise clusters on Rugna’s mythology, a possession outbreak whose rules are revealed gradually rather than explained, and whose shocks grow out of the characters and the rural Argentine setting rather than arriving on cue. Several reviews also single out the craft, in particular the widescreen photography, the score and the practical effects, and most agree the violence is brutal, unflinching and staged with real skill.

The reservations gather in the second half. The Los Angeles Times finds the climax rushed, Paste finds some third-act choices too mystifying, and Collider thinks the setup is laboured. The spread is fairly wide. Polygon sits at the top, treating the film as a memorable revival of possession horror, while IndieWire is the only dissenter of note, finding it mediocre and saying it squanders a promising opening by losing momentum.

Slant Magazine
13 October 2023 · ★★★/4 · Steven Scaife
75

Scaife finds the film disturbing and truthful in its depiction of a world overtaken by human failures. He praises Rugna’s inventive, gradually revealed mythology and the way its shocking images emerge from character and context.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
6 October 2023 · Amy Nicholson
70*

Nicholson finds the film an enjoyable, unpredictable horror thriller, though its rushed climax weakens the emotional payoff. She praises Rugna’s sustained dread and skillfully staged, brutal violence.

Read the full review →
Variety
5 October 2023 · Dennis Harvey
70*

Harvey finds the film uneven but engrossing, ultimately calling it a bracing and unpredictable ride. He praises its atmospheric craft, especially the widescreen cinematography and unsettling score.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
64*

The page is blocked, so the critic’s verdict cannot be determined. The review’s specific praise or complaint is also unavailable.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
3 October 2023 · Nikki Baughan
64*

The accessible text confirms this is a review, but does not reveal the critic’s verdict. The standfirst describes rural Argentine horror centered on an ancient evil.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
14 September 2023 · C · Wilson Chapman
57

Chapman finds the film feverishly mediocre, saying it squanders an intriguing premise and loses momentum in its second half. He praises the opening’s restrained world-building, which lets the audience piece together the rules of demonic possession.

Read the full review →
Polygon
6 October 2023 · festival review · Tasha Robinson
95*

Robinson calls the film a terrifying, memorable revival of possession horror. She particularly praises its carefully built world and family drama, alongside its strong performances and shocking practical effects.

Read the full review →
Paste
7 October 2023 · 8.1/10 · Aurora Amidon
81

The review finds the film an original, nightmarish horror story that is also exceptionally fun. It praises the restrained cinematography and score, while noting that some third-act actions are too mystifying.

Read the full review →
/Film
23 September 2023 · 8/10 · Rafael Motamayor
80

The review praises the film as a disturbing, gory, and smart take on possession horror. It singles out Rugna’s expansive world-building and the way the story conveys a terrifyingly ordinary demonic infestation.

Read the full review →
Collider
16 September 2023 · B · Chase Hutchinson
77

Hutchinson finds the film a brutally effective, dread-filled horror ride, despite some narrative weaknesses and a belabored setup. He praises its relentless, chaotic violence and willingness to deliver gruesome scares without pulling punches.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
7 October 2023 · Jennie Kermode
75*

Kermode finds the film deeply unsettling and compelling, praising how its possession-plague premise explores the human response to catastrophe. She singles out its haunting atmosphere and moral challenge, while noting its devastating tragedy and disturbing violence against children.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
24 October 2023
75*

The headline presents Rugna’s possession film as disturbing yet wonderful. It singles out the film’s horrifying approach to possession.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate