The critics split on When You’re Strange, and the negatives have the edge. What nearly all of them agree on is the archival footage: previously unseen film of Jim Morrison and the band on stage, pristine recordings and intimate scenes, with one concert sequence of fans and hostile police singled out. Even the harshest reviews concede the footage is the film’s strongest asset, and the warmest, in The Guardian and Empire, call the documentary gripping and essential for fans.
The disagreement is over what DiCillo does with that material. Most critics find the narration simplistic, several call the film shallow on the cultural context around the band, and the sharpest complain that it is dull and reverent, reducing the Doors’ story to a flat retelling. Variety and Slant are the fiercest dissenters, both arguing that the editing and voiceover squander the footage. The spread is wide: a few recommendations, a cluster of measured three-star verdicts, and nearly half the reviews firmly negative.
