Wild Rose (2019)

Felperin finds the film entirely delightful and fresh, with a predictable structure that adds to its appeal. She especially praises Jessie Buckley’s magnetic singing and acting performance.

Chang finds the film a deeply satisfying, nuanced crowd-pleaser about ambition, family, and self-discovery. He especially praises Jessie Buckley’s performance for making Rose-Lynn’s confidence and vulnerability feel emotionally coherent.

Rife finds the film standard as a show-business fairy tale but special as a character study. She singles out Jessie Buckley’s commanding performance and expressive singing for praise.

O'Sullivan gives the film a warm, strongly positive review, while noting that some plot turns feel too Hollywood. She especially praises Jessie Buckley's singing and performance, along with the film's female talent.

Webb gives the film an enthusiastic verdict, praising Jessie Buckley’s energetic performance and the spirited supporting cast. She especially highlights the film’s musical performances and closing song.

The review says this funny, touching musical drama mostly hits the right note. It singles out Jessie Buckley as sensational in the lead role.

Kermode finds the film uplifting and bittersweet, praising its ability to connect country music with the heroine’s struggles. He singles out Jessie Buckley’s gripping performance, especially its balance of bravado and vulnerability.

The review finds the film sparky and hugely likeable, praising Jessie Buckley’s energetic performance. It singles out her as the force behind this lively Glaswegian take on a musical-star story.

Edelstein finds the film’s overall construction schematic but ultimately moving and truthful. He especially praises Jessie Buckley’s brilliant, uncanny performance and the rousing final song.

The critic finds the film engaging, though not entirely definitive, as it turns a familiar setup into a thoughtful story about motherhood and ambition. Jessie Buckley and Julie Walters are singled out for their beautifully paired performances.

Smith finds the film an empathetic, unpredictable take on the familiar rise-to-stardom story. He praises Jessie Buckley’s dynamic performance and the film’s nuanced portrayal of Rose-Lynn’s competing responsibilities as a singer and mother.

The standfirst signals a positive verdict on the drama. Halligan singles out Jessie Buckley’s performance for praise.

Kemp finds the film warmly optimistic and occasionally clichéd, but ultimately tender and comforting. She singles out Jessie Buckley’s magnetic, authentic performance and the conviction of her relationship with Julie Walters.

Lane finds the film an uneven take on the familiar follow-your-dream story, made compelling by Jessie Buckley’s fierce, untamed performance. He particularly praises Buckley’s presence and the vividness of her singing and character.

The page is blocked, so the critic’s verdict cannot be determined. No praise or complaint from the review is available to report.

The URL identifies this as a review of Tom Harper’s Wild Rose. The article text is inaccessible, so its verdict and any singled-out praise or complaint cannot be determined.

The critic calls the film a must-see and praises its universal take on an underdog story. Jessie Buckley’s performance is singled out as phenomenal, with Nicole Taylor’s script and Tom Harper’s direction also commended.

The critic is strongly positive, calling the film beautifully crafted and tender. Jessie Buckley’s convincing, charismatic performance as Rose is singled out for particular praise.

The review finds the familiar story stirring and unexpectedly engaging, chiefly because of Jessie Buckley’s performance. It especially praises her electric singing and the film’s nuanced treatment of a mother balancing family and ambition.

The critic calls the film a warm, inviting crowd-pleaser and credits it with avoiding familiar music-movie clichés. They single out Jessie Buckley’s charismatic, sincere performance as the film’s central strength.

Harrison praises the film as emotionally rich and satisfying, despite a slightly slow second act. He singles out Jessie Buckley’s magnetic performance and the moving mother-daughter dynamic, especially Julie Walters’ work.

Kermode finds the film lively and emotionally engaging, with a strong sense of place. She especially praises Nicole Taylor’s quickfire script and the way the music conveys Rose’s feelings.

The critic finds the film an affecting, timely story that balances crowd-pleasing appeal with a subversive turn. They praise its perceptive depiction of the pressures facing working-class mothers and female creatives.

Dunn finds the film a delightful crowd-pleaser that grows into an emotionally satisfying story. He singles out Jessie Buckley’s powerful acting and singing, especially her struggle to balance ambition with motherhood.