Most critics welcome Platonic as a funny, warm account of friendship in middle age, with praise concentrated on Rose Byrne and Seth Rogen. Their chemistry makes the reunited friends’ affection and dysfunction believable, and the reviews repeatedly credit the series for avoiding a forced romance. The writing also earns approval for its grown-up dialogue and attention to ageing and personal change, while the brisk pace helps keep those concerns light.
The reservations concern how well the rest of the series supports its leads. IndieWire finds the surrounding elements weaker than the central partnership, while Paste objects to repetitive hijinks and an overreliance on substance use. The spread runs from enthusiastic approval to outright dissatisfaction: Variety is notably colder, finding the tone inconsistent and the treatment of the characters’ privileged problems uncritical. For most critics, though, the performances and humour outweigh the predictability and unevenness.
