Star Trek: Picard (2020)

The critic says the episode is exceptionally well written and directed, with its character-driven turns making familiar revelations powerful. They praise Picard’s return to the Borg cube and the empathy shown toward former Borg, while faulting the scant follow-up to Jurati’s shocking actions.

Jolin finds the series a welcome, forward-looking return for Star Trek and its beloved captain. He praises Picard’s enduring empathy and the show’s character-focused approach.

Robson calls the premiere an impressive, emotionally engaging start and says it could become a worthy addition to the canon. He praises the action, special effects and Stewart’s quietly intelligent performance.

Chavez finds the series a rousing, forward-looking return that balances nostalgia with new stories, though its packed plotting and action sometimes struggle to find their footing. She singles out Patrick Stewart’s vulnerable, soulful performance as Picard for praise.

The review finds the series hokey and short of prestige-TV polish, but says it comes close to balancing nostalgia with a modern story. It singles out Patrick Stewart’s performance as sensational.

The review is cautiously positive about the series, despite finding its approach less adventurous and more weary than earlier Star Trek. It praises Patrick Stewart’s reassuring presence and Shakespearean diction in the allegorical future.

Seale finds the comeback solid, though not exceptional, and is cautiously hopeful about where it goes next. He praises Picard’s moral conviction and the series’ thoughtful ethical questions, while noting the opener’s heavy exposition.

Fienberg mostly likes the series’ methodical world-building but finds its opening episodes overly slow and exposition-heavy. He singles out Patrick Stewart’s effortless authority as the strongest reason to watch.

The critic finds the series initially hesitant and slow-moving, but ultimately promising enough to keep watching. Patrick Stewart’s performance as a retired, uncertain Picard is singled out as a major strength.

The critic finds the series intriguing but uneven, saying it lacks the curiosity and chemistry that make Star Trek work. Patrick Stewart’s tender, regretful performance is singled out as a compelling strength.

The critic finds the series needs more optimism to work at its best. They call for more Jonathan Frakes and less Borg torture.

Lovitt calls the final season an exceptional return to The Next Generation and a fitting send-off. She praises how its clever storytelling makes the reunion feel natural while balancing franchise lore with fresh adventure.

The reviewer finds the premiere a thoughtful, successful return that updates Picard for a changed world while preserving his essential character. She praises its handling of Picard’s history and empathy, while criticizing Dahj’s thin characterization.

The critic finds season three a major improvement and calls it the best Next Generation movie they never got. They praise its familiar relationships and starship setting, while faulting one episode’s heavy-handed nostalgia.

Lowe finds the third season finally delivers an engaging reunion adventure for The Next Generation crew, though it does not reach the original series’ heights. He praises the crew’s clever teamwork and the awe-inspiring deep-space phenomenon in one episode.

The critic finds the series balances its familiar roots with a fresh direction and recommends it warmly. They single out Number One the dog as a meaningful symbol of Picard’s trauma and attachment to his past.

Lindbergh finds the series a worthwhile, quiet departure from the familiar Star Trek template. He singles out Patrick Stewart’s return as a remorseful, less remote Picard for praise.

The critic finds the series promising but not yet engaging, and says it needs to tighten its pacing. Patrick Stewart’s return is a standout, while convoluted plotting and clunky dialogue hold the show back.