The reviews are sharply divided, with half positive and the rest mixed or negative. Praise clusters around the recreation of 1981 Los Angeles, the visual style and Igby Rigney’s lead performance, which earns approval even from some detractors. Supporters find a compelling mix of adolescent unease, nostalgia and lurid horror in the adaptation of Bret Easton Ellis’s novel. For them, its interest in youth and identity gives the excess something to work with.
The disagreement is over whether that excess remains entertaining or becomes shallow and tedious. Reservations centre on uneven pacing, tonal detours and unreliable suspense; even favourable reviews identify heavy-handed narration or a loss of focus. Variety praises the lead performance but argues that the changes undermine the novel’s mood and ambiguity. Vulture likewise sees an adaptation that loses the book’s nuance, finding neither sufficient fun nor compelling horror.
