Critics’ reviews

A Minecraft Movie (2025)

19 reviews from 19 publications. Critics’ score 50: 4 positive, 5 mixed, 6 negative.

Back to our review of A Minecraft Movie

50
Positive
4
Mixed
5
Negative
6

The reviews split almost evenly three ways, and the spread is wide. Most critics agree on what works: Jared Hess’s absurdist streak, Jack Black’s full-throttle turn as Steve, and his double act with a self-mocking Jason Momoa, with Jennifer Coolidge picked out more than once for the small-town scenes. The comedy-minded reviews find it a likeable, goofy quest that wisely refuses to take itself seriously. The reservations cluster around the story: a borrowed Jumanji-shaped plot, thin stakes, a muddled second half and a sense that the game’s open-ended, build-anything spirit has been swapped for a generic blockbuster template. Several critics call it closer to an advert than a film. The British press is markedly colder than the American trades: The Times awards it nothing at all and calls it commercial propaganda, and The Independent finds Black desperate rather than funny, a view a few others share once the first act’s laughs run out.

Los Angeles Times
2 April 2025 · Amy Nicholson
80*

Hess infuses the adaptation with his signature absurdist humor and touchstones like tater tots and competitive dorks, delivering a solid, goofy comedy anchored by Jack Black's committed performance.

Read the full review →
Variety
2 April 2025 · Owen Gleiberman
70*

Hess brings genial camp and absurdist flair to this weightless quest comedy, with the standout chemistry between Jack Black and a self-skewering Jason Momoa making it likably goofy despite thin stakes.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
2 April 2025 · Brian Tallerico
65*

The film rises above typical video-game adaptations thanks to flashes of quirky personality from director Jared Hess, though it falls short of its potential with muddled plotting in the second half.

Read the full review →
Total Film
2 April 2025 · ★★★ · Neil Smith
60

The critic praises Jared Hess's indie sensibilities and Jack Black's energetic star turn for elevating the adaptation into an entertaining fantasy adventure. Some elements like special effects and female roles are weaker, but it succeeds overall as a playful, irreverent caper.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
2 April 2025 · C- · Jacob Oller
50

The film jams together too many familiar plots and clichés into a chaotic, erratic mix that feels like a first in-game creation rather than tapping the game's imaginative flexibility. It offers occasional flashes of Hess-style surrealism and fun from Jack Black and Jason Momoa, but buries them under generic blockbuster obligations.

Read the full review →
The Independent
2 April 2025 · ★★ · Clarisse Loughrey
40

The critic finds the film an underwhelming and flawed adaptation that fails to capture the spirit of the game. Jack Black's performance as Steve comes across as desperate and clownish, while the story offers little creativity or reinvention.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
9 April 2025 · Richard Brody
40*

The movie is overly conventional and promotional, unlikely to entertain even children, but fans of Hess may appreciate its nods to his distinctive cinematic universe of quirky, personal details.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
4 April 2025 · ★★ · Robbie Collin
40

The placid, open-ended charm of the video game source material is nowhere to be found in this grindingly generic brand extension. The film fails to turn the game's creativity into an engaging feature-length plot.

Read the full review →
Empire
4 April 2025 · Dan Jolin
30*

The critic calls it a hyperactive hot-pink mess that revels in its failure to elevate the source material. It is loud and energetic but lacks story, character depth, or meaningful engagement with the Minecraft world.

Read the full review →
The Times
3 April 2025 · Kevin Maher
0

The film is an unapologetic cranium-crusher and piece of dire propaganda for the bestselling video game, with ugly cash-grabbing designs and a lumpen splodge of commercial propaganda directed by Jared Hess.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
4 April 2025

The critic praises the film's fanciful adaptation that builds imaginative worlds and delivers cross-generational joy through adventure and humor. They highlight its clever use of the game's sandbox nature and nostalgic elements as a strength for family audiences.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
2 April 2025

The film offers full-throttle star turns from Jack Black and Jennifer Coolidge that raise laughs but are undermined by perfunctory plotting. It is an enjoyable if hectic experience overall.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
2 April 2025 · Lovia Gyarkye

The critic finds the film disappointing and mindnumbing for failing to spark imagination or experimental play in the spirit of the game, despite its IP origins. It succeeds visually for novices in showing the Overworld's potential and championing childlike wonder, but lacks stakes, tone, and character development.

Read the full review →
Vulture
4 April 2025 · Bilge Ebiri

The critic praises the film as a funny, lively comic delight that captures the game's playful vibe through the chemistry of Jack Black and Jason Momoa. It succeeds as a silly, light-footed quest comedy thanks to the director's tongue-in-cheek approach.

Read the full review →
Deadline
4 April 2025 · Dessi Gomez
75*

The critic praises the film's embrace of creativity and the strong performances by Jack Black and Jason Momoa, noting it has heart and effective visual effects despite niche humor. They single out the message of nurturing creativity in young Henry and the bromance between the leads.

Read the full review →
/Film
4 April 2025 · 7/10 · Witney Seibold
70

The critic views the film as a broad, slapstick farce that wisely avoids taking itself or the source material too seriously. Jack Black is singled out for praise as the perfect Steve in a quirky, fun adaptation that echoes the director's earlier indie comedies.

Read the full review →
Collider
4 April 2025 · 5/10 · Nate Richard
50

The critic views the film as a disposable family movie that will please young audiences but feels stale and unremarkable to adults. They single out the first act's laughs and the silly performances by Jason Momoa and Jennifer Coolidge for praise, while complaining that Jack Black's performance grows tiresome and the emotional elements feel half-baked.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
2 April 2025
50*

The critic finds the film offers no surprises, aimed squarely at fans with fan service and slapstick, enjoyable for them but formulaic with unremarkable CGI integration and over-the-top Black performance; praises some charming elements like Coolidge and small-town scenes.

Read the full review →
NME
3 April 2025 · ★★ · Ali Shutler
40

The critic notes moments of surreal brilliance and gorgeous visuals embracing the game's quirky culture, including a Technoblade tribute and fun subplots, but finds the film far too safe overall. It feels more like an advert for the game than a celebration of creativity, with a basic Jumanji-style plot that lacks innovation despite the premise.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate