Critics’ reviews

A Silent Voice: The Movie (2016)

11 reviews from 11 publications. Critics’ score 78: 10 positive, 1 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of A Silent Voice: The Movie

78
Positive
10
Mixed
1
Negative
0

Most critics respond warmly to A Silent Voice, praising its emotionally direct treatment of bullying, guilt and the difficulty of seeking forgiveness. Praise clusters around Naoko Yamada’s direction and animation that conveys distress through small gestures, expressions and carefully chosen details. The reviews value its attention to teenage social life and the lasting harm experienced by both victims and perpetrators, with several finding its treatment of regret unusually honest and affecting.

Reservations centre on pacing and how much story the film tries to accommodate. Some critics find the middle section loose or identify shortcomings in perspective; The Hollywood Reporter describes an ambitious but overstuffed adaptation while praising its precise visual and sonic detail. The spread is fairly narrow, with ten positive responses and one mixed. The Guardian offers the most restrained assessment, though it still appreciates the film’s emotional warmth and evocative framing.

Variety
13 June 2017 · festival review · Maggie Lee
85*

The review highlights the film's beguiling animation and fresh take on school bullying from the bully's perspective, praising its emotional depth and visual style, though noting some narrative tightening needed in the midsection.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
15 March 2017 · 3/4/4 · Michael Leader
80

The critic calls it a quietly affecting coming-of-ager that broadens the definition of anime in the UK with its emotional, slice-of-life melodrama. They single out the film's awkward, off-centre animation style and its impact despite some narrative and perspective shortcomings.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
19 October 2017 · Charles Solomon
80*

The critic praises the film's unflinching depiction of bullying and its honest exploration of atonement and regret, while noting some pacing issues in its long runtime. It stands out for its emotional depth compared to typical American animated features.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Trevor Johnston
80

The critic views it as a cultural breakthrough for its positive portrayal of a deaf student and insights into bullying, self-esteem and despair. They single out female director Naoko Yamada's direction full of unexpected turns and images suggesting a fresh way of looking at the world.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
18 March 2017 · ★★★★ · Robbie Collin
80

It is an intricate, romantic and jewel-bright high-school melodrama about the changing relationship between a deaf teenage girl and the boy who bullied her. The critic highlights its account of teenage politics and notes it as a rarity steered by three women.

Read the full review →
Time Out
6 March 2017 · ★★★★ · Trevor Johnston
80

The critic praises this insightful Japanese animated high-school drama as standing alongside the best of Studio Ghibli, highlighting its challenging take on bullying, guilt and redemption. They single out director Naoko Yamada's distinctive creative direction and fresh worldview.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
15 June 2017 · festival review · Jordan Mintzer
70*

The film condenses a popular manga into an ambitious but overstuffed story of bullying's long-term ripple effects on both victims and perpetrators. Yamada excels at depicting the characters' interior worlds through precise visual and sonic details that highlight the divide between the protagonists.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
19 March 2017 · ★★★
60

The film is a real tear-jerker about a young man seeking forgiveness from the deaf classmate he bullied as a child. The critic praises its lush emotional embrace and evocative framing that focuses on details like bruised knees.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
14 March 2017 · festival review · Jane Fae
80*

The critic highlights the film's complex exploration of bullying from multiple perspectives, including self-loathing and the difficulty of absolution, delivered through visually stunning anime that is funny, engaging, and ultimately heartwarming despite its heavy themes.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
16 March 2017 · ★★★★ · Gloria Daniels-Moss
80

The critic praises the film's emotional depth in exploring bullying, self-hatred, and redemption through nuanced animation techniques focusing on expressions and gestures; it's a poignant coming-of-age story that moves viewers but doesn't leave them feeling warm and fuzzy.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
2 March 2017 · ★★★★ · Ross McIndoe
80

The film captures the existential anguish of high school life, where everyday dramas feel like profound quests. Yamada's hazy, nostalgic visual style suits the themes of guilt and memory, while the colourful, finely-tuned characters make the story engaging.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate